The defense attorney for Tyree Saunders told jurors Wednesday that prosecutors simply couldn’t prove his client sold the fentanyl to Jeremy Clark that killed him.
“There’s a lot of circumstantial evidence,” Joseph Horowitz argued during his closing. “It just doesn’t add up to anything.”
Saunders, 27, is charged with drug delivery resulting in death stemming from Mr. Clark’s March 22, 2017, overdose death. Trial began Tuesday before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman. The jury deliberated briefly Wednesday afternoon before breaking for the day.
Investigators were able to track the drug sale to Saunders, detectives testified, after reviewing text messages they found in Mr. Clark’s phone in which he was setting up the deal on the evening of March 21.
After Mr. Clark’s body was found slumped over on his mattress in a house on Carnegie Avenue in Clairton, the detectives pretended to be Mr. Clark and set up another drug deal with Saunders.
He was arrested a short time later when he arrived to make the sale, police said.
Read More
But Mr. Horowitz told the jurors in his closing that the prosecution’s key witness, Christina Stuart, who said she had been with Mr. Clark since she was 14, lied throughout her testimony.
“Frankly, she was more unbelievable than I even expected her to be,” he said.
Ms. Stuart, who is facing her own separate charges of possession of drug paraphernalia, testified that Mr. Clark overdosed about 12:30 a.m. on March 22, and she revived him, only to find him the next afternoon deceased.
When she found him, she testified that she tried to kill herself by using the two remaining stamp bags next to him. When that didn’t work, she said she cleaned up all of the empty stamp bags and hid those and a syringe in the kitchen.
She told the jury that Mr. Clark had been living with her for three weeks and that she was no longer using drugs.
However, another witness testifying for the prosecution — Ms. Stuart’s cousin — said that Mr. Clark was not living there at the time he died, and that they weren’t together. She also said Ms. Stuart was an active drug user at the time.
Mr. Horowitz raised the prospect that it could have been Ms. Stuart who gave Mr. Clark the fatal dose that night.
“Your evidence is from a heroin user who lied to you about being a heroin user,” he said.
Mr. Horowitz called Ms. Stuart’s testimony about cleaning up the overdose scene “far-fetched.”
The defense attorney also spent several minutes theorizing that someone else could have been using Saunders’ phone the night the drug deal was made with Mr. Clark.
“Nobody knows who was using that phone that day,” Mr. Horowitz said.
But Assistant District Attorney Jonathan Lusty said it was pretty clear who was using it.
Saunders had the phone with him when he was arrested the day of Mr. Clark’s death as he was meeting to sell the undercover officer drugs.
Saunders also identified himself as “Ty,” several times when texting people on the same phone in the days leading up to the fentanyl sale to Mr. Clark, Mr. Lusty said. He used the same colloquialisms and spelled the name of the fentanyl he was selling, “NBA Finels,” incorrectly, the prosecutor said.
“Ladies and gentlemen, is there any question who had that phone?” Mr. Lusty asked the jury.
At 7:20 p.m. on March 21, Mr. Clark texted Saunders and asked when he was getting more drugs.
Saunders answered, “I got two left for a buck,” Mr. Lusty said, meaning he had two bundles of 10 stamp bags each, to sell for $100.
Saunders texted Mr. Clark and said it was marked “NBA Finels,” and was a blue and white stamp — the same bags Ms. Stuart said she cleaned up from around Mr. Clark’s body.
The text messages continued for about 40 minutes, Mr. Lusty said, and the two men made arrangements to meet.
“There is no doubt Tyree had the phone,” the prosecutor said. “He sent those text messages. He set up the deal.”
As for Ms. Stuart, Mr. Lusty conceded that she did lie during her testimony.
“Of course she did,” he said. “She’s a drug addict.”
But whether she used with Mr. Clark that night or not, Mr. Lusty continued, “Why would Christina make this up?
“The commonwealth’s job is to prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. But it’s not to disprove any theory the defense can make up. It’s not our job to give you every piece of evidence that’s possible in the world.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.