After leaving two jail board meetings early when activists began arguing with board members and interrupting speakers, Allegheny County jail oversight board chairman Judge David R. Cashman resigned Friday as a board member.

Judge Cashman, of the Court of Common Pleas criminal division, had been a member of the board since 2014. President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark is responsible for appointing his replacement. Traditionally, the president judge’s designee chairs the board.

In a resignation letter sent to Judge Clark and the board, Judge Cashman wrote, "I have enjoyed the time that I have been on this board and the opportunity to work with other members of the Board and the Jail staff. I appreciate the accomplishments that we have achieved in reducing the population of the Jail and the cost of its operation. That being said, however, it would appear that I have become a lightning rod for the animosity directed at the Board by the individuals who purport to represent the transgender population of Allegheny County."

Cashman Resignation (PDF)

Advertise with us

Cashman Resignation (Text)

Judge Cashman continued that the board has "attempted to accommodate those individuals" but has "not been able to quantify their particular problems, and, as such, they have become more frustrated and combative. Their attitude toward members of the Board has been antagonistic, vituperative, and vindictive.

"I do not believe it would be in anyone's best interest for me to continue as a member of this Board."

Judge Clark said she had yet to select a replacement, but would be meeting with Judge Jill Rangos, who is administrative judge for the criminal division, as well as county Executive Rich Fitzgerald and other judges to attempt to name one as quickly as possible.

“I wasn’t present for the events that happened, so I have no comment on those. But I want to thank Judge Cashman for his tireless work the past few years as chair of the oversight board. I have been chair of the oversight board. I know it’s a considerable amount of work and time the chair has to put in. It’s been a difficult situation so I want to thank him for all that he did,” said Judge Clark.

Advertise with us

After a group of transgender former inmates and advocates repeatedly spoke at meetings on their complaints about the jail, Judge Cashman held a special meeting on the issue July 22. He left the meeting early, however, after an activist got into an argument with one of the board members.

Then, at Thursday’s regular board meeting, activists repeatedly interrupted speakers with questions and criticisms, leading to the arrest of two and an early end to the meeting.

The board is tasked with “the operation and maintenance of the prison and all alternative housing facilities, the oversight of the health and safekeeping of inmates and the confirmation of the chief executive's selection of a warden,” according to a state ordinance.

The board is composed of the president judge or — as in this case — her designee, the sheriff, a second judge, the county controller, the county council president, three citizen representatives appointed by the county executive and the county executive himself. Several members, including county Executive Rich Fitzgerald and county Controller Chelsa Wagner, tend to send representatives in their stead.

Christopher Huffaker: 412-263-1724, chuffaker@post-gazette.com, or @huffakingit on Twitter.