Psychiatrists for both the prosecution and defense agree that a Swissvale woman accused of stabbing her 8-day-old baby two years ago did not know that what she was doing was wrong because, at the time, she was experiencing delusions and hallucinations from schizophrenia.

Both sides in the criminal case believe that Tanishia Fielder, 34, should be found not guilty by reason of insanity.

She is charged with two counts of attempted homicide, aggravated assault and related charges stemming from the Sept. 8, 2017, incident at her home.

On Monday, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski presided over a nonjury trial in which both the prosecution and defense agreed Ms. Fielder needs treatment.

Advertise with us

The prosecution has asked that Ms. Fielder be held in the secure, civil side of Torrance State Hospital in Westmoreland County for treatment, while defense attorney Andrew Capone has asked that his client be released to a community treatment team.

The judge said he will render his verdict within 14 days.

Ms. Fields had previously been diagnosed with — and treated for — paranoid schizophrenia, but when she became pregnant, her physician told her the Haldol injections she had been taking would be harmful to the baby, so she discontinued them.

Although she said she did not have any hallucinations during pregnancy, according to a report by Dr. Bruce Wright, the prosecution's expert, Ms. Fielder began having auditory hallucinations the day she brought her son home from the hospital, Sept. 8, 2017.

"I was at the hospital. I brought him home. Everything was fine," she told Dr. Wright. "When I went in there to get something, it was a strong feeling, through my eyes. I looked in the bassinet. The voices came out and said kill him. I don't know how to kill no one. They said take the baby out of the house. I took the baby outside the fire escape. They said don't take the baby in the house. The voice said the house will blow up. I kept taking the baby outside. Voices told me to kill the baby, and if Darwin gets in the way, kill him, too. Voices said that's the devil's baby."

Advertise with us

In interviews with Allegheny County detectives, Ms. Fielder's boyfriend, Darwin Hanner, told them that he thought she was handling the baby roughly that day, and he picked the child up.

Ms. Fielder then grabbed a knife she had hidden under her pillow and chased him and the baby.

Ms. Fielder's son had knife wounds near his right eye. Mr. Hanner sustained superficial wounds.

According to the police report, after Mr. Hanner got the baby away from Ms. Fielder, two witnesses tried to help, and Ms. Fielder chased them with the knife to an apartment building next door.

When police arrived, they found Ms. Fielder sitting on the stoop of the rear of the building. She told them, " 'I stabbed the baby, that's the devil baby ... The building is going to blow. God wanted me to stab the baby.'"

Advertise with us

After her arrest, medical records during her first few days at the Allegheny County Jail showed Ms. Fielder was initially psychotic, refused her medication, yelled all day, cried, was hostile and agitated.

Dr. Wright described her as "profoundly psychotic," delusional and as experiencing auditory hallucinations.

During her stay in the jail, physicians were able to stabilize Ms. Fielder, according to the defense report written by Dr. Sara West, and by late October 2017, she was "'doing much better.'"

Ms. Fielder was then sent to Torrance State Hospital, where she stayed from Jan. 24, 2018, until April 11, 2018.

There, she was diagnosed with schizophrenia. Ms. Fielder reported having been diagnosed at age 23 and said she had been hospitalized several times.

Advertise with us

Upon discharge from Torrance, experts there recommended Ms. Fielder have follow-up treatment in a structured environment.

Both Drs. Wright and West agreed in their reports that Ms. Fielder's actions in attacking her son were driven by her schizophrenia.

Because of her psychotic symptoms, Dr. Wright wrote, "Ms. Fielder did not know that what she was doing was wrong."

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.