A fraternity that was kicked off Penn State University’s campus after the death of a pledge has filed a federal lawsuit against the university, claiming among other things that its rights of due process and equal protection were violated.
Beta Theta Pi fraternity is seeking more than $500,000 in damages in the seven-count lawsuit, filed Friday in U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania by attorneys Michael P. Leahey and Daniel R. Michelmore. They say the university “engaged in a course of conduct intended to unfairly punish the chapter.”
The lawsuit also claims the university wanted the chapter disbanded so it could acquire the fraternity’s property at below-market value.
Asked for comment, Penn State spokeswoman Lisa Marie Powers directed a reporter to a university website with details about Greek life on campus.
The complaint comes after Penn State banned the fraternity in March 2017 following the death of 19-year-old Timothy Piazza in a hazing incident at the house the month before.
Defendants in the complaint include Penn State, its president, Eric J. Barron, the vice president of student affairs, Damon Sims, and Danny Shaha, senior director of the Office of Student Conduct.
Read More
The complaint cited a violation of the Constitution’s 14th Amendment under due process rights. It said Penn State officials failed to provide notice of an investigation and other proceedings against the chapter, didn’t provide information or evidence under review in the investigation, didn’t provide a hearing or other opportunity for the fraternity to tell its side of the story and didn’t provide access to videotapes that were reviewed in the investigation.
The complaint says the fraternity’s House Corporation has suffered financial damage in “defending against Penn State’s continued attempt to force the sale of the Beta House to them at well below market value.”
The lawsuit argues in its equal protection claim that Penn State singled out the chapter because “similar conduct by other organizations did not result in a campus ban levied by the Penn State administration.”
Mr. Leahey and Mr. Michelmore argue that Penn State’s intent of “disparate treatment” of the chapter was not to “fix the drinking culture at Penn State,” but to repurchase the Beta house property located in a “valuable location in the middle of campus.”
Mr. Piazza’s parents reached a settlement with Penn State earlier this year for an undisclosed amount.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.