Update on Mustafa Alowemer

A federal magistrate judge on Friday ordered a young Syrian refugee living in Northview Heights to be held  on charges of plotting to bomb a church in the name of the Islamic State to which he pledged loyalty.

After a preliminary hearing that featured detailed FBI testimony about the undercover investigation that revealed the plan, U.S. Magistrate Judge Cynthia Reed Eddy said prosecutors had shown probable cause to hold Mustafa Mousab Alowemer, 21.

The slightly built Mr. Alowemer arrived in court in an orange jail suit and listened impassively to the proceedings through an Arabic interpreter, although he speaks some English and corresponded on social media in both English and Arabic.

Dozens of observers, including Mr. Alowemer's relatives and supporters, packed the courtroom along with media members, all under the eyes of a large contingent of court security officers and U.S. marshals.

Advertise with us

The FBI arrested Mr. Alowemer Wednesday following an investigation that began in 2018.

The bureau's terrorism unit in Pittsburgh said he planned to use a backpack bomb to blow up Legacy International Worship Center, a tiny church on Wilson Avenue, in the name of the Islamic State.

Since the spring he had corresponded with two FBI operatives who posed as Islamic State sympathizers and arranged four meetings with them in furtherance of the plot, according to testimony from FBI Agent Gary Morgan.

He wanted to blow up the church, which he described as Christian and Nigerian, to take revenge for his Islamic State "brothers" in Nigeria, Agent Morgan said.

"Mr. Alowemer laid out the plan entirely," he said.

Advertise with us

After the arrest, he said, Mr. Alowemer confessed to agents at an interview at the FBI building on the South Side.

He admitted to plotting the bombing, meeting with the undercover agents to carry it out, sending them bomb-design manuals and buying bomb-making materials, including nails that would act as shrapnel.

"Mr. Alowemer stated that he knew that what he was doing were terrorist acts," Agent Morgan said.

The agent said Mr. Alowemer explained that he "felt pressured" and "felt an inner drive" to carry out the attack but that Mr. Alowemer did not elaborate further.

Agent Morgan said Mr. Alowemer, who grew up in Jordan and came to the U.S. as a refugee in 2016, had initially wanted to attack a Shia mosque in Pittsburgh but rejected the idea because it had too much security and because Sunni Muslims also worshipped there. Mr. Alowemer is Sunni.

Advertise with us

Believing one of the FBI undercover operatives to be a bomb expert, he later settled on the church and presented detailed plans on how to carry out the attack, Agent Morgan said. His plan was to place a bomb equipped with a 10-minute timer in one car and park it near the church, then take another car and drive to a mosque to be seen at morning prayers to establish an alibi when the bomb went off.

The plot also called for one of the undercover agents to monitor the Zone 1 police station for response once the bomb exploded and detonate a second bomb to kill police after they arrived at the scene.

Agent Morgan said Mr. Alowemer wanted the Islamic State to be given credit for the bombing, not himself, and suggested leaving a note at the scene saying "We've arrived."

He also said a search of Mr. Alowemer's house turned up some 40 items related to the investigation, including a distinctive mask he is seen wearing in a video he sent to the FBI agents during which he swore an oath of loyalty to the leader of the Islamic State.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Soo Song said the government had enough evidence to hold him, including the many detailed online conversations outlining the plot and four face-to-face meetings at a location north of Pittsburgh with the two agents.

Advertise with us

"This defendant affirmed his intentions with his behaviors and actions," she said.

His lawyer, Sam Saylor, argued that the judge had heard only the FBI's version of events and suggested that Mr. Alowemer was only bragging as young men do. His line of questioning suggested he plans to pursue an entrapment defense or that the FBI misinterpreted his client's intentions.

"We've only heard one side of the story here," he said.

He also said that just because Mr. Alowemer bought items at hardware stores — such as nails, acetone and ice packs — doesn't mean he intended to build bombs.

The judge sided with the government.

Advertise with us

Mr. Alowemer waived his right to an additional hearing on detention and U.S. marshals took him away.

After the hearing Bob Jones, special agent in charge of the Pittsburgh FBI, addressed the media in the courthouse lobby and promised that the bureau will continue to pursue terror investigations. The bureau, he said, has 5,000 international terrorism cases ongoing at any one time.

"Once again we see a peaceful congregation of worshipers targeted simply because of their faith," he said. "The Federal Bureau of Investigation cannot and will not let this stand in a country that holds the free exercise of religion as one of its most basic freedoms."