The federal government tried again Tuesday to lock up Thomas Stultz, accused of arranging for sex with an undercover FBI agent he thought was a teenage boy, but a federal judge again denied the request.
U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab said Mr. Stultz, although charged with a serious crime, can remain free on bond pending trial on a coercion charge.
The U.S. attorney's office had argued at a previous hearing that Mr. Stultz, 36, of Bellevue, be detained as a danger to children not only because of the coercion count but because of new evidence that Mr. Stultz molested a real 14-year-old and expressed interest in molesting a 5-year-old girl.
A federal magistrate judge, Robert Mitchell, rejected that argument and placed Mr. Stultz on home detention with monitoring and no internet access.
Prosecutors tried again Tuesday to send him to jail, but Judge Schwab sided with Judge Mitchell.
"In sum, [Stultz] has illustrated that he is able to comply with the conditions set forth by Magistrate Judge Mitchell, that he does not pose a threat of danger to the community, and moreover, that he will appear at court proceedings," the judge wrote.
Mr. Stultz is among three local men arrested this spring in separate FBI sting operations in which agents posed as underage boys on the Grindr gay dating site.
He was arrested outside Heinz Field on April 15 after he took a bus there to meet the boy for sex, according to FBI testimony. Agents were waiting for him and took him into custody.
Judge Mitchell initially released him but prosecutors later said new information had surfaced that caused them to seek detention.
A forensic review of his phone showed chats with a real boy, now 15, dating back two years.
When the FBI tracked down the boy, he told them he had met Mr. Stultz on Grindr and the two had sex at Mr. Stultz's house, according to agents.
The phone evidence also revealed a conversation Mr. Stultz had with an adult male in which the man talked about molesting a 5-year-old in a hotel. Mr. Stultz expressed interest in participating, according to the FBI. The phone also contained child porn images, agents said.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Heidi Grogan argued that all of the phone evidence, combined with the charge involving the undercover agent, proves Mr. Stultz is a threat to molest children if he gets the chance.
"The best predictor of what a defendant will do is what they have already done," she said. "He's a danger to the community."
But Mr. Stultz's lawyer, Lyle Dresbold, argued that his client is in psychosexual therapy and has abided by all the conditions of his release, so shouldn't be locked up.
At issue is the nature of the charge. Since Mr. Stultz isn't accused of coercing a real child, Mr. Dresbold said the federal law that governs pretrial detention, called the Bail Reform Act, does not mandate that his client be detained. In federal court, unlike state court, the burden is on defendants to prove why they shouldn't be jailed pending trial for certain crimes.
"It [the law] says 'minor child' and there was no minor child," he argued.
Judge Schwab indicated at the hearing which way he was leaning when he noted that prosecutors have not charged Mr. Stultz with a crime in connection to the new evidence, so there is no real victim.
He let him go and set a trial date for Dec. 2.
The FBI said Mr. Stultz, using the online name "darkzero," contacted an undercover agent on Feb. 6 on Grindr. The agent posed as a 14-year-old.
Mr. Stultz propositioned the boy and the two exchanged pictures and texts over the following weeks until they agreed to meet, agents said. After several plans fell through, they set up a meeting in April at the T stop outside the football stadium.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.