Brandon Wolowski — a convicted killer who tried to rob his friend’s gun safe in Washington County in 2013 and then fatally shot the man in the back as he ran away — was spared the death penalty by a jury but will go to prison for life.

Common Pleas Court Judge John F. DiSalle on Thursday sentenced Wolowski, 24, to state prison on a first-degree murder charge in the Jan. 8, 2013, killing of Matthew Mathias, 37. He has no chance of parole and was also convicted of attempted homicide, aggravated assault, and two counts of robbery.

Judge DiSalle tacked on a consecutive sentence of 22 to 44 years for shooting Mr. Mathias’ girlfriend, Michelle Powell, in the face during the same incident and for the robbery counts.

Authorities said Wolowski went to Mr. Mathias’ house on Fayette Street in Washington to steal his guns.

Advertise with us

“He had talked about the fact that he was facing eviction. He had a small child at the time. He needed money,” Deputy District Attorney Leslie Ridge said Friday.

She said Wolowski had seen guns in the house on previous visits and believes he schemed to rob Mr. Mathias of them and then sell the firearms. His plan, according to Ms. Ridge: to bring crack cocaine to the house, smoke it with the victims and then catch them off guard.

The evening started according to Wolowski’s plan, with the group smoking crack. Around 7:25 p.m., Wolowski pulled a revolver. But he apparently didn’t count on Mr. Mathias saying he needed to retrieve a code for the safe — and then running out the front door.

“I don’t think he anticipated that the one victim would run out the door,” Ms. Ridge said.

Wolowski followed and gunned Mr. Mathias down in the front yard, shooting him in the back. He returned to the house and turned his gun on Ms. Powell, who was 39 at the time. He shot her in the face, chest and arm.

Advertise with us

She survived and was able to tell police that “Brandon” had shot her, according to an affidavit. Police found him nearby.

Ms. Ridge said Wolowski confessed to his crime, though his attorneys tried to suppress the admission of guilt during lengthy pre-trial sparring, a change of defense counsel and a request to evaluate Wolowski’s competence to stand trial.

A jury heard the case in March and convicted Wolowski. Prior to trial, Wolowski had rejected a plea deal of 30 to 60 years in prison.

Jurors denied the prosecution’s request for the death penalty, determining that mitigating factors, such as the defendant’s difficult upbringing — during which he was abused — outweighed aggravating circumstances, such as a homicide committed during commission of a robbery.

“We always respect what the jury decides. I think our biggest thing was getting the first-degree murder conviction,” Ms. Ridge said.

Advertise with us

Afflicted by seizures and hearing loss resulting from the shooting, Ms. Powell managed to testify. Her scars were visible — on her face, arms and stomach. She requires help at home from an aide and is limited in what she can do, Ms. Ridge said.

“But for the grace of God she survived,” Ms. Ridge said.

Wolowski’s attorney could not be reached Friday for comment.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.