Sheltered from the pouring rain under a curved stone archway in the courtyard of the Allegheny County Courthouse, a small group of people Friday protested the treatment of a county jail inmate who gave birth while incarcerated, and they called for the criminal justice system to change the way it handles substance abuse.
Stop on separating families in jail
“We know and understand that addiction is a public health crisis, an epidemic, but what we don’t recognize is the crisis and health epidemic in the way our country treats its most vulnerable,” said state Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale. “Increasingly we lean toward a punitive system that never seeks to rehabilitate and always seeks to punish.”
Joss Deuerling, 31, of McKees Rocks, got caught up in that punitive system, Ms. Lee and others said Friday. Deuerling pleaded guilty to several drug-related crimes in 2016, according to court records. She was sentenced to between nine and 18 months in prison and served 12 months, her attorney, Bret Grote, said Friday.
Deuerling, who has struggled with addiction, in February failed a drug test and as a result was arrested for violating the terms of her probation. She was nine months pregnant at the time and gave birth Feb. 7 at a local hospital two days after she was taken into custody, Mr. Grote said.
Deuerling was not allowed to contact the baby’s father when she went into labor, and her family was not allowed to be present during the birth, Mr. Grote said, adding that a sheriff’s deputy stayed in the room the whole time. Deuerling was limited in the time she was allowed to hold her infant, he said, and she was not allowed to shower for two days.
A few days after giving birth, Deuerling was returned to the Allegheny County jail for about two months while she waited for a probation violation hearing, Mr. Grote said. The baby, who Mr. Grote said is healthy, is in her father’s care.
Read More
At the March probation hearing, Common Pleas Judge Anthony M. Mariani ordered Deuerling to go to a state prison to be evaluated for a possible drug treatment program.
Mr. Grote said that assessment will last for several weeks — weeks that Deuerling will be separated from her baby — and said that separation harms both mother and child. He argued Deuerling should have been released on probation so she could receive treatment at home and with her family.
“He is going to separate her from her child under the mistaken notion that this will help her address her substance abuse disorder,” Mr. Grote said. “Incarceration does not provide treatment for substance abuse disorder … the criminal legal system is utterly ill-equipped to deal with drug addiction.”
Amie Downs, county spokeswoman, said the jail disputes Mr. Grote’s account of Deuerling’s experience giving birth, but she said the jail is prohibited from discussing the case due to patient privacy laws.
However, Laura Williams, the jail’s chief deputy warden of healthcare services, said in a written statement that per jail policy, inmates are not allowed to contact family members when they are being transported to healthcare facilities outside of the jail because of security concerns.
She also said incarcerated pregnant women are not allowed to have their family present during birth “because of their status as an inmate.”
Additionally, she said sheriff’s deputies assigned to guard hospitalized inmates “must maintain visual contact ... within a reasonable proximity unless it would compromise the capacity to provide emergent care.”
How much time a mother spends holding their newborn and when the mother showers is not determined by the jail or by the sheriff’s deputies, but by the healthcare provider, Chief Deputy Warden Williams said.
Ms. Lee said Friday the way the criminal justice system handles women — and pregnant women in particular — needs to change. This year, she introduced a bill that would keep pregnant women who are convicted of nonviolent offenses from being sentenced to jail time. The bill would require that such women be sentenced to alternative housing or treatment programs, rather than to a jail or halfway house. The alternative sentence could include parenting classes and vocational training, she said.
House Bill 1009 was referred to the House Judiciary Committee on April 2. It’s part of a larger package of bills aimed at changing the way incarcerated women are treated in the criminal justice system, Ms. Lee said.
Mr. Grote said at the end of the day, his client was receiving treatment for drug addiction when she relapsed — and that relapse should not have landed her back behind bars.
“Relapse is part of recovery,” he said.
Shelly Bradbury: sbradbury@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1999 or on Twitter @ShellyBradbury.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.