Saying she couldn't understand why the owner of a successful Carnegie software firm willfully failed to pay more than $2 million in payroll taxes, a federal judge rejected his request for home detention on Thursday and sent him to prison.

While 20 of Amarender Tiparthy's friends and family looked on, U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose ordered him to serve two years behind bars.

As owner of Prodigy Software Group, Tiparthy didn't pay $2.2 million in payroll taxes from 2010 to 2013 while at the same time building a $500,000 house in Coraopolis and putting it in the names of his wife and sister.

Tiparthy had waived indictment last year and pleaded guilty.

Advertise with us

His friends and his lawyer, William Difenderfer, argued for probation, saying Tiparthy is a kind-hearted family man who has done extraordinary charity work in the Indian community. Tiparthy argued that he had paid some of the money back during the years in question and Mr. Difenderfer noted that his client did not appear to be siphoning off money from the company as is often the case in tax fraud schemes.

But Assistant U.S. Attorney Mary Houghton disputed that, saying Tiparthy had been the subject of IRS tax collection efforts for 15 years and that he built a fancy house while not paying what he owed to the U.S.

She said the $2.2 million in back taxes makes the case among the largest payroll tax cases seen in this district and argued that giving Tiparthy probation would send a "horrible message" to other tax cheats.

"I think it shows greed, your honor," she said.

Judge Ambrose sided with the prosecution. She said Tiparthy had ample opportunity to pay what he owed yet chose not to. She also disputed Mr. Difenderfer's assertion that Tiparthy was not living high while ripping off the government. The lawyer said a $500,000 house is hardly lavish but the judge said it is, at least in Western Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

"I think a half-million-dollar house is not a modest house in Pittsburgh," she said.

Tiparthy, who was 50 when he pleaded last year, was the sole owner of Prodigy, which provided companies and government agencies with consulting services for information technology.

Tiparthy collected payroll taxes, including Medicare and Medicaid and Social Security, for 16 quarters from 2010 to 2013 but didn't turn the money over to the IRS.

Judge Ambrose said that in her experience the IRS goes "out of its way" to work out tax liabilities before resorting to criminal charges. But that Tiparthy refused to pay.

"I just don't understand it," she said.

Advertise with us

In addition to the prison term, she ordered him to pay the full amount to the IRS.

Tiparthy has started a new company and is living in Virginia with his mother. His house here is up for sale.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.