The U.S. government wants to present witnesses to finger a Manchester man for murder even though he's not charged with the killing.
His lawyer says that's an attempt to skirt the U.S. Constitution and is asking a judge to block it.
This federal court battle over the fate of Glenn Thomas, 29, is the latest chapter in the long-running investigation of the Price Montgomery drug ring, which culminated in Montgomery’s conviction last year for the 2014 murder of federal witness Tina Crawford in the Hill District.
Prosecutors have long believed Thomas was the second shooter in that murder.
But he was never charged with homicide. Instead, he was indicted and pled guilty to being an accessory after the fact for ditching the getaway car in Virginia.
He was supposed to be sentenced last week but the hearing instead became a debate over the legality of allowing witnesses at a sentencing hearing to say he's a killer.
Read More
U.S. District Judge Mark Hornak heard arguments Wednesday and will decide after reviewing motions.
At issue is the concept of punishing defendants for uncharged conduct, a common occurrence in the federal court system.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Shaun Sweeney said he intends to produce three or four witnesses at the sentencing hearing who will say Thomas was the second shooter.
The idea is to convince Judge Hornak to give Thomas the maximum sentence of 15 years for being an accessory.
But Thomas' lawyer, Lee Rothman, said that's an unfair move and cited several U.S. Circuit Court opinions in other cases that would seem to bolster his contention that such enhancements for uncharged crimes are a due process violation.
Mr. Rothman said the government shouldn't be allowed to hold a "mini trial" at sentencing to punish his client for something they couldn't prove to a grand jury or at a trial.
He said the government shouldn't be allowed to "circumvent" his client's plea agreement by trying to introduce evidence at sentencing.
He said if the government thinks his client is a killer, prosecutors should indict him and put him on trial.
"Instead of charging [Thomas] with these crimes, the government is attempting to hold a mini-trial under the ruse of 'uncharged conduct' to significantly enhance [Thomas'] sentence," Mr. Rothman said in court papers. "If the court considers this proposed evidence, [Thomas] could be sentenced as if he actually committed a homicide and/or was a drug dealer without the government having to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that [Thomas] committed those crimes."
In court, he suggested that the prosecution strategy is to take advantage of the lower standard of proof at federal sentencing hearings. The witnesses would be testifying under the civil standard of preponderance of the evidence as opposed to the criminal standard of beyond a reasonable doubt.
"I felt compelled to attack this," he told the judge.
He asked the judge to either bar the testimony or to make a ruling on his ability to impeach the witnesses as he would in a criminal trial.
Mr. Sweeney, who prosecuted Montgomery, said the government never sought to indict Thomas for murder but that seeking the upward variance is appropriate considering the case.
He said the government was not confident enough in its evidence to get an indictment for homicide but sought from the beginning to introduce related conduct at the sentencing to give Thomas the maximum under the accessory statute.
Mr. Sweeney said the government is allowed to seek a variance at sentencing by introducing evidence of a defendant's character, conduct and history.
"In the instant case, the government intends to offer evidence of the defendant’s uncharged conduct pertaining to his involvement in the killing of Tina Crawford," he wrote. "There is nothing improper about seeking an upward variance based upon uncharged conduct of a defendant, as a defendant’s conduct, of course, relates to the history and characteristics of the defendant under [the law]."
Among the witnesses Mr. Sweeney intends to call is an informant charged under seal in 2016 with heroin distribution who said he was with Montgomery and Thomas on the day of the shooting and heard them talking about Ms. Crawford's cooperation with law enforcement.
After the murder, he said Thomas came to his house in an agitated state and told him that he and Montgomery had shot Ms. Crawford and her mother, Patsy, who was wounded, according to testimony from IRS Agent Jamie Ball.
The witness also said that Thomas told him that Montgomery had dropped his cell phone at the scene, according to the prosecution. That phone became the key piece of physical evidence in the case after agents found Montgomery's DNA on it.
The witness is due to be sentenced in federal court at the end of the month.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.