It came as a shock in early December to many of the people in Elizabeth Borough’s downtown business district when they learned that police Chief Tim Butler had been placed on administrative leave.

On Thursday, in this small riverfront community that’s working toward revitalization, there was still not much more news as to what happened to force the four-year chief and longtime officer out of the department.

Earlier in the week, staff from the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office did an inventory of the police department’s property room to determine if anything was missing.

Otherwise, no one is talking.

Advertise with us

Sgt. Garrett Kimmell, who is now in charge of the department, said he cannot speak to the personnel issue.

And Mayor Barry Boucher said he would wait for the DA’s office to finish its review before he speaks publicly.

He noted, though, that a public borough council meeting is scheduled for Tuesday evening.

Nikki Williams, the general manager of Fellini’s Pizza on Second Avenue, said the chief has stopped to eat there before and is friendly.

“I’ve never heard anything negative. It was shocking,” she said.

Advertise with us

Steve Ziacan, who owns Simply You Soap & Candle Co. across the street on Second Avenue, said his experience with the borough police has always been good.

He and his wife see officers patrolling through the business district once in a while and see them, too, at various community events like the Thursday nights summer concert series on Plum Street and at holiday parades.

His store, which sells custom, handmade soaps and candles — The Perfect Man claims to “smell like a unicorn” — opened in April 2017, and since then he has seen a number of other shops open, including Snowy’s Chocolates across the street and the Steel Lotus — previously the Teal Lotus — gift shop around the corner on Plum Street.

Most folks in the business community aren’t worried about what’s happening with the chief. They say the officers in the department — there are two full time and 10 part time — have worked hard in recent years to clear out people selling drugs on the street, and they note a regular police presence there.

“Whatever riffraff was down here is basically gone,” Mr. Ziacan said. “People are excited that new shops are opening up.

Advertise with us

“It’s going through a revitalization.”

Lynne Blewitt and her husband, Mark Massaro, own Snowy’s. She never heard anything negative about Chief Butler, either.

“It’s a tough job,” Mr. Massaro added. “I think he did as well as he could.”

Others said that the chief was actively involved in doing good works in the community, including helping to organize and participate in providing meals to those who needed them on Thanksgiving Day. He was also easy to deal with and listened to business owners’ concerns.

They regret what’s happening in the police department but don’t feel like it is going to imperil the community.

Advertise with us

Ashley Bokus, who is the co-owner of the Steel Lotus, said she sees the potential for much more growth in the downtown area. A microbrewery is expected in the spring, and there are discussions about closing off Plum Street in the summers to make it like a town square.

“There was never anything to do down here,” she said. “I don’t think it will be like that in a few years.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.