Six months after the killing of 17-year-old Antwon Rose II by East Pittsburgh police Officer Michael Rosfeld reignited calls for an Allegheny County-wide civilian police review board, county council members will introduce Tuesday an ordinance to create one.

The bill, sponsored by members DeWitt Walton and Paul Klein, would initially only cover the Allegheny County Police Department, but any county municipality lacking its own board could opt in. According to Mr. Klein, the leadership of one borough, Sharpsburg, has already said they would be interested in opting into the board's coverage.

The ordinance creates a board with the ability to investigate allegations of misconduct and then to recommend actions, either to prosecutors or to relevant municipalities and police departments, but no power to compel action. If an agency does not hand over documents or witnesses, the board would be able to ask the courts to intervene, and if it determines misconduct happened, it can refer the case to state or county prosecutors, or recommend that the police department discipline the officer or make reforms.

"What we're trying to do is protect the rights of citizens and ensure that law enforcement officers that are intent on doing their jobs to the best of their ability are protected as well," said Mr. Walton.

Advertise with us

"We can't file charges," he underscored.

To protect law enforcement the ordinance requires that if the board receives what it believes is a false accusation, it refers that to the district attorney's office as well.

The board could respond to complaints filed by citizens, or open investigations at its own discretion.

"The impetus for this was the killing of Antwon Rose back in June," said Mr. Klein. "This was a tragedy, so what do we do to make things better going forward?"

Amie Downs, spokeswoman for County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, said he would have no comment on the bill until after the council vote, but Mr. Fitzgerald has previously told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, "There needs to be someone who has the ability to look at police operations."

Advertise with us

In July, eight of the council’s 15 members voted to hold public hearings on the issue. None of the six members who voted against that motion responded to requests for comment.

"Some members of council have sent a letter to every municipality saying that this legislation is going to be introduced," said Mr. Walton. "This time, however, they have not asked people to oppose it. When they sent the letter out in the summer, they were asking the municipalities to oppose it."

"Those who opposed it, I think their thinking was, if we don't have jurisdiction over these municipalities, what's the point?" said Mr. Klein.

State law prohibits the county from imposing civilian oversight on municipal police departments, but the County Police Department is the county's second-largest force, after the city, and already provides policing for one municipality, Wilmerding.

Sharpsburg Mayor Matthew Rudzki confirmed he would support opting the borough into a county civilian police review board.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rudzki highlighted a provision of the ordinance requiring board members to attend police academy training. “They’re getting the same trainings the officers get,” he said.

Mr. Klein said one reason the limited jurisdiction could be helpful is that smaller, budget-constrained departments are looking at cutting their police forces and having the county take over, if possible. "The county and the county police could be playing more of a role that they have not been playing historically, so we want to be proactive and forward-looking so we can forestall those bad things from playing out."

After Antwon's shooting, East Pittsburgh asked the county to take over its policing, but due to funding issues, this month it was disbanded, with state police taking over. The borough was also part of a meeting earlier this month exploring police regionalization. The proposed ordinance has a provision for consolidated departments to opt in to board oversight. It does not, however, cover non-municipal departments, like Mr. Rosfeld's prior employer, the University of Pittsburgh Police Department.

Khalid Raheem, who helped organize the Committee for a Civilian Police Review Board of Allegheny County, declined to comment on the bill, but previously said of the push for a review board, "It provides a broader and wider scope in terms of oversight for police misconduct. That creates a sense of police accountability, and not accountability from police supervisors. It would be made up mostly of civilians throughout Allegheny County."

The ordinance limits the board’s nine members to a maximum of two former police officers, and zero active officers. It also requires there be at least one experienced attorney or auditor and that the board’s membership reflect the county's diversity, although "there are no specific quotas," said Mr. Walton. County council would appoint six members, and the county executive three, for a maximum of two four-year terms.

Advertise with us

The board's operating budget, for expenses including staffing, legal services and office space, would be determined as part of the county's annual budget process.

At Tuesday's regular county council meeting, the ordinance will likely be referred to committee with no final vote until the new year, said the sponsors.

Christopher Huffaker: 412-263-1724, chuffaker@post-gazette.com, or @huffakingit