Westmoreland County Sheriff Jonathan Held let his ego run amok and drove public resources into his own re-election efforts, a state prosecutor charged Tuesday, painting a withering portrait as the sheriff’s criminal trial opened in Greensburg.

“What this case is really about is the defendant’s ego. It’s his ego and his belief that he, as an elected official, is above the law,” said Bobbi Jo Wagner, a deputy attorney general, in her opening statement.

The state Attorney General’s office accused Sheriff Held in February of directing on-duty deputies to collect political contributions for his 2015 re-election bid. His trial on three charges — conflict of interest, which is a felony, and two theft counts — is expected to last a few days.

The theft charges, both misdemeanors, stem from using county-paid labor and equipment for political purposes, Ms. Wagner said.

Advertise with us

“You’re careful with your money. He wasn’t,” she told jurors.

Ryan Tutera, Sheriff Held’s attorney, rejected implications that his client pressured workers in the sheriff’s department to help him win re-election. Sheriff Held, 44, of Claridge, has denied the allegations against him.

“Nobody was told what to do. Nobody was commanded or threatened on what to do,” Mr. Tutera said in his opening statement. “You have to remember that these people did [campaign work] voluntarily, for whatever reason — reasons of currying favor in the office, reasons of not wanting to do this on their own time because they had other things to do such as family life, such as other interests outside of work.”

Mr. Tutera also questioned witness credibility, saying that some expected to testify had lied to investigators.

Jurors heard Tuesday morning from the trial’s first two witnesses: county Detective Randall Gardner and Vince Izzo, who retired this year as a lieutenant in the sheriff’s department.

Advertise with us

County officials began looking into Held campaign activities in 2016, when Paul McCommons, a former chief deputy under Sheriff Held, brought forth allegations, Detective Gardner testified. Mr. McCommons was among the candidates for sheriff in 2015.

Mr. Izzo, in his testimony, acknowledged soliciting gifts in 2015 and 2016 for campaign events. He estimated spending a total of about 24 to 28 hours on the solicitations during three months in 2015. Most of that time he was on the clock for work, he said.

Mr. Izzo also said that he volunteered for the campaign activity but wasn’t told when to do it. Mr. Izzo testified that he traveled in a county vehicle to make overtures. Sheriff Held and some other workers in the department discussed the efforts on work time, and the results were logged at their county offices, the former lieutenant said.

He sometimes concealed contributions in a Walmart shopping bag when he brought them back to the workplace, he said. Offerings included prizes to be awarded at the campaign gatherings, dubbed “I Out-Shot the Sheriff.”

Eventually, the state Attorney General’s office took over the investigation into campaign activities. Workers in the sheriff’s department suspected of talking to the AG’s agents were reassigned internally, Mr. Izzo said.

Advertise with us

When Sheriff Held believed one officer in particular had been talking to the AG’s office, Mr. Izzo said, the sheriff and a department chief had that officer reassigned. The man moved from the warrant office to the “bullpen,” a rough assignment that deals with prisoner holding cells, Mr. Izzo said.

Mr. Tutera soon challenged Mr. Izzo over the accuracy and completeness of his past statements. The retiree acknowledged that he held back some information in an initial interview with investigators looking into Sheriff Held.

Mr. Izzo also said he faced no internal repercussions after he spoke with the AG’s office.

Earlier, Mr. Tutera told jurors there’s “more to the case than the commonwealth wants you to think.” Workers in the sheriff's department who questioned campaign activity ended up in less desirable jobs there, according to the prosecution.

But people were moved for “a variety of legitimate reasons that you’ll hear about,” Mr. Tutera said.

Advertise with us

“Nobody was fired. Nobody was demoted to the point where they lost considerable sums of money,” he said. “Don’t buy into that.”

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.