A Beaver County district judge on Tuesday held for court some charges against Aliquippa police Assistant Chief Joseph Perciavalle III after a marathon preliminary hearing that featured testimony from the department’s now-suspended police chief as well as a sergeant who exercised his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.
District Judge Ed Howe dismissed several charges against the suspended assistant chief, who was charged with sending a sexually explicit text to 18-year-old Lauren Watkins in June, when she was 17. He was also separately charged in July with secretly recording a conversation with police Chief Donald Couch, who is on administrative leave.
District Judge Howe dismissed two felony charges related to the explicit text, and held for court a misdemeanor count of corruption of minors. He also held for court a felony charge that stemmed from the recorded conversation.
Assistant Chief Perciavalle was first charged after detectives found the explicit text on Ms. Watkins’ phone while they investigated the killing of teacher Rachael DelTondo, 33, who was shot to death in her driveway on May 13. Ms. Watkins, the daughter of Aliquippa police Sgt. Kenneth Watkins, was one of the last people to see Ms. DelTondo alive.
As investigators searched her phone in connection with the homicide, they discovered a video text message from Assistant Chief Perciavalle to Ms. Watkins, her father and her mother in which a woman urinated while swinging in a park.
Assistant Chief Perciavalle’s attorney, Steven Townsend, argued in court Tuesday that the message was sent by mistake and that his client did not realize Ms. Watkins was a minor. Ms. Watkins, who testified that she is a sophomore in college after finishing high school a year early, said she didn’t remember if she saw the explicit text sent by Assistant Chief Perciavalle, whom she considered an uncle.
Read More
“I honestly couldn’t tell you if I opened it or not,” she said, although she added she did see the image when detectives questioned her about it later.
She said she felt pressured by detectives with the Beaver County District Attorney’s office to write a statement about the text, and said she did not want to pursue charges against Assistant Chief Perciavalle.
“It was basically, if you don’t write this then your parents are going to get — ” she said, before Assistant District Attorney Angela Reed Strathman shouted an objection.
“You’re turning this into a fishing expedition against detectives,” she said to Mr. Townsend.
Ms. Watkins was not allowed to clarify her statement, but Mr. Townsend previously told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that detectives threatened to charge Sgt. Watkins with failing to report the incident to state authorities as child sexual abuse. Police officers are mandated to report such incidents.
Sgt. Watkins refused to answer any questions about the content of the text message when he took the stand Tuesday, and said he was invoking his right not to incriminate himself. He testified he feared prosecution and “retaliation from the DA’s office.”
Father and daughter declined to comment after the hearing.
Aliquippa police Chief Don Couch — who was placed on leave in June for an unspecified reason — testified about a recording that detectives found on Assistant Chief Perciavalle’s phone. The conversation between Chief Couch and the assistant chief was recorded on March 2, the same day that Pennsylvania State Police executed a search warrant on Aliquippa city offices in connection with a grand jury investigation into allegations of theft.
Chief Couch testified Tuesday that he discovered the state police raid when he stopped by the city offices to drop off mail, and returned to his station afterwards, where the state police investigation was all everyone was talking about.
Chief Couch testified that as he listened to the conversations, Assistant Chief Perciavalle implied several times that he knew why state police were at the city offices.
“His comments led me to believe he knew more about what was going on than I did,” Chief Couch testified. “I was puzzled.”
He told Assistant Chief Perciavalle to join him for “a ride,” he testified, and said they got into Chief Couch’s car and drove around Aliquippa before parking for several minutes.
“My goal was to find out what he knew through a conversation,” Chief Couch said.
The subsequent 39-minute conversation was secretly recorded by the assistant chief. It is illegal to secretly record a private conversation in Pennsylvania. During the profanity-laden conversation, which was played in court, Assistant Chief Perciavalle told Chief Couch that the state police investigation was about the city’s pension fund and emphasized it had nothing to do with the police department. The two speculated about who was involved and why.
“Shame on them if they did something,” Assistant Chief Perciavalle said on the recording. “We didn’t do [expletive.]”
Chief Couch called the raid “another black eye for the city” in the recording. The conversation also strayed to personal family matters, as well as administrative matters regarding the police department and its budget. Chief Couch testified he never gave the assistant chief permission to record the conversation.
Mr. Townsend suggested in court that the chief and assistant chief were in separate cars, talking to each other through their open windows in a public parking lot, and so the chief had no expectation of privacy and the recording was legal. Chief Couch testified that some of the conversation may have taken place in separate cars, but said he couldn’t recall at what times the two were in a single car or in separate cars.
Mr. Townsend also argued that the recording was legal because Assistant Chief Perciavalle was afraid Chief Couch was about to commit a “crime of violence” against him. Mr. Townsend suggested the chief believed Assistant Chief Perciavalle was working with state police and was angry about that.
Chief Couch said on the stand he would not have tried to stop the assistant chief from cooperating with state police, but rather would have offered to help. The chief admitted on cross-examination that he was a little upset the assistant chief did not loop him in.
“I’m his chief, he should tell me,” he said, adding later, “But he’s an experienced officer, and I was not going to persecute the kid for doing what he thought was right.”
Mr. Townsend refused to say whether Assistant Chief Perciavalle was working with another agency to investigate Aliquippa officials. A detective for the district attorney’s office testified that the assistant chief was not working under the authority of state police when he recorded the conversation.
Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier and Assistant Chief Perciavalle declined to comment.
Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.