When an Allegheny County judge asked whether detectives and the teen special-needs victim in a sexual assault case were satisfied with a proposed plea deal, the girl's mother popped up in the back of the courtroom.

"I don't like the plea bargain, that there's not a felony charge based upon the evidence," the woman said.

Common Pleas Judge Mark V. Tranquilli tried to reassure her.

"No one is in a better position than the trial prosecutor to make a determination as to the evidence," said the judge, a former longtime homicide prosecutor. He said he had to defer to the district attorney's office, noting that it must prove charges beyond a reasonable doubt.

Advertise with us

But as the hearing Tuesday progressed against Lavalle Tucker, Judge Tranquilli changed his mind and rejected the deal, calling it "unacceptable."

Mr. Tucker, 71, a driver for Pittsburgh Limousine Service, was accused Dec. 19 of touching a 17-year-old student while parked in a van outside the Children's Institute in Squirrel Hill. He faced two felony counts of aggravated indecent assault after a witness reported to police that she saw his hand in her pants and between her legs.

Under an agreement with prosecutors, Mr. Tucker would plead guilty to four lower-level misdemeanor charges — two counts of indecent assault, corruption of minors and endangering the welfare of children. Each count carries a maximum prison term of five years.

That was not what the victim's mother wanted, however. And Judge Tranquilli was swayed by the evidence against Mr. Tucker that was presented by the prosecution.

Assistant District Attorney Lisa Carey said lab tests showed that Mr. Tucker's hands were swabbed on scene and tested positive for the victim’s DNA.

Advertise with us

In addition, the prosecutor said, there was an eyewitness: A woman walking her dog that evening told investigators that she saw through a window Mr. Tucker touching the young woman. She banged on the van and called the police.

The alleged victim has Cri-du-chat syndrome, a rare genetic disorder, and is mostly non-verbal.

During the hearing, she became visibly upset and again later after it concluded.

Following the hearing, her mother said that she was pleased by the judge's decision.

“I’m hopeful they move forward in a better fashion so we can get justice for Lavalle Tucker,” she said. “We’re going to put him in prison.”

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette does not identify alleged victims of sexual assault.

Mike Manko, a spokesman for the DA's office, said that prosecutors made the offer based on the allegations they believe they can prove.

"The plea offer presented today encompassed those four charges, with no agreement as to sentencing and a lifetime sex offender registration,” he said. “As with any child sex assault case, the welfare of the victim is paramount and we are confident that today’s action was appropriate in holding the defendant responsible and in allowing the victim to avoid the trauma both of a trial and potentially being placed on the witness stand.”

The mother said in an interview that the incident with her daughter has turned her into an advocate. She believes that school districts and transportation companies need to get aides and cameras on all buses.

“Sexual assault is such a serious situation in today’s world. it’s everywhere, and if we don’t do the right things and give the consequences to the actions, I think that is just going to continue,” she said. “I’m elated the judge is not going to let this fall through the cracks.”

Advertise with us

The case is now scheduled for trial on Feb. 26.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.