A man shot a police sergeant and three other people Wednesday inside the Masontown Borough Municipal Center, where he was scheduled to appear at magisterial district court to face domestic violence charges.
Patrick S. Dowdell, 61, of Masontown, then was shot and killed by a German Township police officer.
Mr. Dowdell walked into the building on East Church Street about 2 p.m. and started shooting, authorities said. All four victims -- including Masontown police Sgt. R. Scott Miller -- had non-life-threatening injuries. Sgt. Miller was the first person to confront Mr. Dowdell after the gunman entered the building’s lobby.
Sgt. Miller was shot and took cover, and Mr. Dowdell continued into the lobby of the building, which houses the courtroom and other offices, and shot two men and a woman, Fayette County District Attorney Richard Bower said, before the German Township police officer “made his way” to the lobby and shot Mr. Dowdell multiple times.
Masontown shooting witness recounts events
The two men, ages 47 and 35, and the 39-year-old woman were treated at Ruby Memorial Hospital in Morgantown, W.Va., and then released, a hospital spokeswoman said.
Attorney Eric Randolph, of Jefferson Hills, said he was inside the courtroom when the shooting began. He heard one shot, then people screaming, and then two more shots, he said.
“People were scrambling over each other yelling, ‘Shooter! Shooter! Shooter!’” he said.
Mr. Randolph moved toward the door of the courtroom of District Judge Daniel Shimshock when it burst open and a man he believed to be the shooter leaned halfway inside and swept his gun across the courtroom, holding it in one hand.
“He pointed the gun right at me,” Mr. Randolph said, adding that the man had facial hair and was wearing a dark-colored T-shirt. The man carried a black semiautomatic handgun, Mr. Randolph said. The man had an intense look, did not fire in the courtroom, and was gone a moment later.
After about five minutes, Mr. Randolph and others in the courtroom were escorted out by police.
Another witness, Christopher Jones, said he was standing in the crowded lobby before the shooting when he recognized Mr. Dowdell as a mechanic who planned to do work on his car. He said he talked with the man but didn't know Mr. Dowdell had a gun.
"He's like, 'Oh man ... they're trying to put me in jail over this girl, and I love her, and I can't live without her,’” Mr. Jones recounted. He said Mr. Dowdell “might have acted the fool today, but he was a good man."
Court was in session when the shooting started, with 30 or 40 cases scheduled to be heard, authorities said. Mr. Randolph said it appeared that District Judge Shimshock and his staff were able to scramble out of the courtroom through a back hallway.
Multiple people injured at Masontown district judge's office
Neither the district judge nor court staff members were Mr. Dowdell’s intended target, said state police Lt. Steve Dowlin. He declined to identify the man's target or say whether the 39-year-old woman who was shot was involved in the prior domestic dispute with Mr. Dowdell. He was arrested Aug. 25 and charged with aggravated assault, terroristic threats, strangulation, simple assault and harassment.
The details of that case were not immediately available, but Mr. Dowdell was scheduled to appear for a preliminary hearing in the courtroom at 1 p.m. Wednesday.
Mr. Bower, the district attorney, said the shooting raises questions of security at magisterial district courts.
“We have concerns there are not enough protections in place,” he said, adding that in this case police officers were able to stop the shooter quickly and prevent additional injuries or deaths because the officers were already in the courtroom for hearings.
“Today they all were a shining light to our community and it goes without saying we must thank them for their heroic efforts,” Mr. Bower said.
“It’s unfortunate that someone lost their life, but I’m proud of my officer,” said German Township police Chief Dave Hromada. “I think everyone did what they were trained to do.”
Mr. Randolph, who has practiced for 17 years, said he hopes the incident prompts authorities to beef up security at district courts, especially in rural areas with small courts that tend to be less well protected.
“They get all sorts of cases, from assault to attempted homicide,” he said. “Domestics tend to be the worst. [That’s when] tempers are flaring and violence is more likely.”
Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter. Staff writer Jonathan D. Silver contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.