In the minutes after a Pittsburgh woman alleges she was assaulted at the Castle Shannon restaurant where she worked, she finished waiting on her table and talked to the man she said attacked her –– the restaurant’s owner –– at the bar.

The defense for Amabile “John” Carbonara intended Thursday for that evidence, presented in video footage in Allegheny Common Pleas Court before Judge Thomas E. Flaherty, to convince the jury to disbelieve the woman’s story.

A day earlier, as the trial began, the former waitress testified that Mr. Carbonara, 56, of Peters spanked her with a back scratcher on Oct. 15 and then groped and sexually assaulted her Oct. 21 in his office in Carbonara's Ristorante & Lounge on Mt. Lebanon Boulevard.

He is charged with indecent assault, harassment and unlawful restraint. His trial will resume Friday.

Advertise with us

The alleged victim testified that after the Oct. 21 incident, she immediately went to the bathroom to compose herself, texted her boyfriend and then left the restaurant. The prosecution played video showing her following Mr. Carbonara into his office at 1:58 p.m. and leaving six minutes later.

But on Thursday, footage presented by the defense showed the woman did not immediately go to the bathroom. Instead, she walked out into the dining area, attended to a table, went to the hostess station, then the kitchen to put in an order. Only then, the video showed, did she go to the restroom.

Defense attorney William Difenderfer, who spent about three hours cross-examining the alleged victim, repeatedly questioned her about her appearance as she left the office after the incident, noting that her blouse was buttoned appropriately and her apron was tied up in a bow even though she claimed she’d just been sexually assaulted.

She explained later on re-direct examination by the prosecution that Mr. Carbonara never untied her apron and instead lifted it up during the assault. The woman testified that she never said she went to the bathroom to put her clothes back on, but instead had gone “to straighten out her mind,” and “gather herself.”

Mr. Difenderfer hammered, too, on the woman’s demeanor, given that she had previously testified that she suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder following childhood sexual abuse.

Advertise with us

In the minutes following her exit from the office, the video footage played by the defense appears to show the woman having friendly interactions with Mr. Carbonara, including engaging him in conversation.

“I didn’t know how to handle what was happening. I tried to be as normal as possible because I still had to work there,” she testified. “I can’t avoid him. He’s my boss.”

“What could possibly be more stressful to a woman than going to an office knowing she’s going to be molested?” Mr. Difenderfer asked.

“Nothing,” the woman said.

During re-direct, Assistant District Attorney Michael Pradines asked the alleged victim to read all of the text messages she sent her boyfriend that afternoon after leaving the office.

Advertise with us

First, she wrote to him that she was going to quit, then she continued, “I’m gonna leave at lunch. I’m so shaky.” And, “I’m scared. I hate this so much.”

When Mr. Difenderfer asked her how she could resume working that afternoon after being victimized, the witness said, “It’s just what I’ve always done. I’m a server. That’s what I do.” She continued, “I was just trying to hold it together.”

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette does not identify alleged victims of sexual assault.

Annie Rosenthal: arosenthal@post-gazette.com or on Twitter at @AnnieRosenthal8.