A Slippery Rock man says in a federal complaint that a since-fired New Castle police officer smashed his head off the floor repeatedly during an encounter last month that was partially captured on video.

Perry L. Lawry on Thursday sued the city of New Castle, Officer Peter Mendincino and former Officer Ronald Williams for claims of excessive force and false arrest on April 23.

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following video contains content that may be disturbing to some viewers:

Officer Williams was fired last week for violating the department's use-of-force policy during the arrest of Mr. Lawry.

Advertise with us

According to the civil complaint, this is what happened:

Neshannock police dropped off Mr. Lawry, who was drunk, at the address of his girlfriend, Kelie Toney, on East Washington Street in New Castle. Mr. Lawry argued with Ms. Toney's 15-year-old son Jeremy, who punched Lawry in the face and knocked him down. Ms. Toney called 911.

Perry L. Lawry (Photos courtesy of The Lindsay Law Firm)

Officer Mendincino arrived, found Mr. Lawry on the kitchen floor and tried to help him up. But because of his drunken state, Mr. Lawry fell into a kitchen island, and the officer ended up on top of him, after which he tried to handcuff him.

Officer Williams then arrived, used his Taser to "dry stun" Mr. Lawry and then punched him in the ribs and head five times. Officer Williams also hit him in the head with his knee.

Ms. Toney yelled for the officers to stop and then was taken into her daughter's room by her son, who began recording the scuffle with his cell phone.

Advertise with us

Officer Williams at that point "began to viciously slam Mr. Lawry's head off the ground at least three times," the complaint says.

In the video, Ms. Toney is heard saying "Don't kill him" and "I think he's dead."

She later saw Mr. Lawry handcuffed on the floor "choking on his own blood" and asked the police to help him, according to the complaint.

When a third officer arrived, the complaint says, Officer Williams said "You saw him go for a knife, right?"

Mr. Lawry did not go for a knife, the complaint says. In addition, it says the third officer hadn't been there for the fight and so couldn't have seen anything.

Advertise with us

In an affidavit supporting the arrest, Officer Williams said he arrived to see his fellow officer wrestling with Mr. Lawry, who he said ran towards a countertop for two knives. Officer Williams said that's when he used his Taser but said Mr. Lawry kept trying to reach the counter.

In the affidavit, Officer Williams said he grabbed Mr. Lawry by the shoulders and "gave him three thrusts shoving his chest and head into the floor until he stop [sic] resisting and handcuffs could be placed on" him.

According to the complaint, Mr. Lawry needed 15 stitches on his face and suffered damage to his head, among other injuries.

After the fight, according to the complaint, Officer Mendincino asked Jeremy Toney if he'd recorded what happened and then confiscated his cell phone, claiming it was "evidence."

But Jeremy had already used Snapchat to post the video on Facebook. The suit is asking for unspecified damages.

Advertise with us

Jason Medure, New Castle's solicitor, said the city hadn't yet received the complaint but when it does will turn it over to the city's insurance company.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.