A man who occasionally was romantically involved with a former cyber school teacher said he was with other people when she was killed in Aliquippa.

A search warrant obtained by Aliquippa police reveals where 20-year-old Sheldon Jeter Jr. says he was Sunday night when Rachael DelTondo, 33, was shot in the driveway of the home she shared with her parents.

Police have not named Mr. Jeter, who was found in a parked car with Ms. DelTondo at 2 a.m. on a dead-end street when he was 17, as a suspect. This is, however, the second warrant police have obtained to search his property in relation to the case — this one for his house and car; the first was for his cell phone.

Mr. Jeter told investigators that the night Ms. DelTondo was killed, he was driving two men, Marquis Jenkins and Amir Sly, to their residence in Center. He said he then drove back to his home on Orchard Street in Aliquippa, according to the warrant.

Advertise with us

He said a woman, whose identity he would not disclose to investigators, drove him to his mother’s house, and his mother’s boyfriend drove him back home about 10 p.m. He said he spent the rest of the night playing a video game.

The search warrant says investigators sought weapons and ammunition at Mr. Jeter’s home, but found none. Investigators, however, seized several items, including notebooks, a Playstation 4 and a car key, according to the warrant.

The warrant also shows that police interviewed Mr. Jeter’s brother, Rashawn Bolton, who told investigators he was in a relationship with Ms. DelTondo. Mr. Bolton said he had witnessed Mr. Jeter threaten Ms. DelTondo.

The first search warrant detailed Ms. DelTondo’s movements in the hours before she was killed.

Lauren Watkins, a friend, picked up Ms. DelTondo about 8 p.m. Sunday and took her to another friend’s house in Hopewell. About 9:20 p.m., Ms. Watkins and Ms. DelTondo left the friend’s house and returned to Ms. DelTondo’s home on Buchanan Street, where Ms. DelTondo changed clothes.

Advertise with us

A few minutes later, the two friends picked up Tyrie Jeter -- Sheldon Jeter’s older brother -- and went to Hank’s Frozen Custard in New Brighton. While there, Mr. Jeter texted Tyrie Jeter, asking whether the group was ‘there already,’ and Tyrie responded that they were. Sheldon then texted, “I got left huh,” followed by six smiley faces, according to the search warrant.

Mr. Jeter then asked Tyrie Jeter who was with him, and Tyrie Jeter did not respond, according to the warrant. At 10:30 p.m., Sheldon texted Tyrie that the ice cream shop was closed.

At 10:44 p.m., Ms. Watkins dropped Ms. DelTondo off at her house and drove Tyrie Jeter home, according to the search warrant. Tyrie told police that Ms. Watkins told Ms. DelTondo that “she would be back.”

Ms. DelTondo was shot to death four minutes later.

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.