The state Superior Court on Monday vacated an Allegheny County jury verdict and ordered a new trial in a negligence case involving Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC because a judge was not present during the jury selection process.

In a strongly worded concurring opinion, two members of the three-judge panel urged Allegheny County’s civil division to revisit how juries are selected for civil trials.

"A judge personally witnessing the original voir dire [the process by which potential jurors are questioned] is essential, because it justifies our — and a losing party’s — faith in the trial court’s rulings on challenges for cause,” the court wrote.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Christine Ward, who oversees the civil division, could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

Jason Zivkovic, who represents Children’s, said he will ask for a rehearing of the appeal by the full nine-member Superior Court and, if necessary, ask the state Supreme Court to take the case.

“We respectfully disagree with their opinion and believe their attempt to change the voir dire process in Allegheny County is misguided,” he said.

The case before the court arose from negligence claims filed by Mendy Trigg, whose daughter had to undergo reconstructive skull surgery for a birth defect at age 4 at Children’s Hospital in 2013.

After the seven-hour surgery, the girl was placed in an adult-sized hospital bed in the cardiac intensive care unit. In the hours following her surgery, she fell out of her bed, landing on her head. The fall caused two skull fractures, displaced her forehead, and caused a blood clot behind her eye.

She had to undergo a second surgery to repair the damage, and since that time, the lawsuit alleged, has had behavioral problems and outbursts.

Advertise with us

The Triggs, of Bellaire, Ohio, sued Children’s for negligence, alleging that the girl should have been placed in a crib following her surgery because she weighed only 29 pounds, was small for her age, was 4 years old and at risk for falling.

Attorneys for Children’s argued that hospital policy said that only children under 4 are placed in cribs, and that the hospital’s medical staff had checked on the child minutes before the fall, and that she was in the bed, at its lowest setting to the ground and with the guard rails up.

The case went to a jury trial in March 2017, and following a weeklong trial, the panel found 10-2 in favor of Children’s, said Harry S. Cohen, the attorney representing the Triggs.

He appealed, alleging that there was error during the jury selection process, specifically regarding three jurors who he sought to have removed for cause because he felt that they could not be impartial.

During jury selection, attorneys representing both sides question prospective jurors about their potential biases and background in order to select and impartial panel.

Advertise with us

As part of the appeal, Mr. Cohen challenged Allegheny County’s method for jury selection. In the civil division, the trial judge is not present when potential jurors are questioned. Instead, a clerk runs the process, and any questions that arise about whether a person should be struck for cause are referred to the Calendar Control judge.

That judge — in the Trigg case it was Ronald Folino — then reviews the transcript of the proceedings and makes a ruling, the Superior Court explained.

In their appeal, the Triggs argued that by not observing the potential jurors' initial reactions and demeanor — as happens in most jurisdictions across the country — a judge is not making a fully informed decision.

Although Mr. Cohen challenged Judge Folino’s decision regarding three potential jurors, the Superior Court addressed only one: Juror No. 29. During questioning, that juror told the attorneys that her sister was a family practice doctor, and her brother-in-law was a pediatrician, both working in Hershey.

During jury selection, Mr. Cohen asked her if, because of her family, she would tend to favor the medical practice in a "close call."

Advertise with us

She answered, "Just, I see what they go through, and I know how much they care about their patients, and I know they would never do anything wrong. Obviously, I realize there are people out there who aren't my siblings. So they may not be as fair and clear in judgment."

Mr. Cohen sought to strike the woman for cause, but Judge Folino denied the request. In a later opinion, he wrote that he believed, looking at her answers as a whole, that she could be fair and impartial and base her verdict on the facts and the law.

By the judge refusing to strike Juror No. 29 for cause, the Triggs were forced to use their last peremptory challenge (an objection to a potential juror that does not require a reason), which the Superior Court agreed was reversible error.

In its opinion, the Superior Court quoted a 2017 state Supreme Court opinion that explains why appellate courts are to defer to trial judges relative to jury selection.

"We defer to the trial judge because it is he or she that observes the juror’s conduct and hears the juror’s answers. The juror appears before the trial judge, who sees him and hears what is said; and is able to form his opinion as much from the proposed juror's conduct as from the words which he utters, printed in the record,” the state Supreme Court wrote. “Hesitation, doubt, and nervousness indicating an unsettled frame of mind, with other matters, within the judge's view and hearing, but which it is impossible to place in the record, must be considered.”

Advertise with us

But the Superior Court noted that since Judge Folino didn't observe Juror No. 29's behavior or demeanor, there is no reason to give that same kind of deference.

"The trial judge acquired none of the wisdom or insight that he could have from noting a juror’s furtive glance, a tremor of voice, a delayed reply, a change in posture, or myriads of other body language,” the Superior Court wrote.

Even if Judge Folino had called the jurors in to recreate the question, the court continued, it "could never reproduce the authentic reactions that they displayed when the questions were originally asked."

In Allegheny County, the Academy of Trial Lawyers formed a committee months ago to study the issue and make a recommendation to the court, but that has not yet occurred.

Alan Perer, an experienced civil litigator in Pittsburgh not connected to the case, said the process of not having a judge present during selection in Allegheny County goes back decades from when the judges were too busy, and there were too many trials underway at the same time.

Advertise with us

“But that was the old days,” he said. “Times have changed.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.