Fear of its side effects has kept Taylor Williams from getting the coronavirus vaccine.

Ms. Williams, 18, who graduated from Oakland Catholic High School in May and will attend the University of Pittsburgh this fall, plans to wait until there is more data on the vaccine before she decides whether to get a shot.

She compared her hesitancy toward getting vaccinated to not wanting to be the first person to ride a new roller coaster: “You want it to go so it gets all the bugs out.”

As the COVID-19 vaccination campaign trudges along, skepticism among young Americans has become an obstacle to achieving mass immunity. According to a recent report by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, just more than a third of Americans between the ages of 18 and 39 had gotten jabbed as of the end of May, compared to roughly half of all Americans.

Advertise with us

In southwestern Pennsylvania, young people also are less willing to get vaccinated than older people, data on the Pennsylvania Department of Health’s COVID-19 vaccine dashboard shows.

As of July 2, 35.8% of the people in Allegheny County between the ages of 20 and 39 had not received a COVID-19 shot, compared to 26.5% of all county residents. In Butler, Westmoreland, Washington and Beaver counties, more than half of all young people are not vaccinated, although each county reports a majority of its residents are vaccinated.

In interviews, people ages 17 to 35 cited a variety of reasons why they have decided to forgo the COVID-19 vaccine. They fall along a continuum of unwillingness: Some say they just haven’t gotten around to it, while others are scared by online reports about the vaccine’s alleged dangers.

In the early stages of the vaccine rollout, public health messaging aimed at older people was relatively straightforward: A vaccine will save your life. But in trying to convince young, healthy Americans — many of whom already tested positive for the coronavirus and experienced just mild illness or no symptoms at all — public officials face a different set of challenges.

A ‘sense of immortality’

Advertise with us

Gabriella Pasqualucci, 17, is the only person in her immediate family who hasn’t been vaccinated. A rising senior at Pine-Richland High School, she said she feels uneasy about getting a shot that has only been available to the general public for several months.

“I personally just don’t want to inject science into me that’s so new to a point where you don’t know long-term side effects,” she said. “There’s been rumors about infertility and stuff, and as a young woman who wants to have children one day, I just don’t really want to risk that.”

Her older sister, a cardiac rehabilitation worker at St. Clair Hospital in Mt. Lebanon, told her there are no scientific studies to support the claim that the COVID-19 vaccine causes infertility, Ms. Pasqualucci acknowledged.

Ms. Pasqualucci said she respects the decision of those who get vaccinated. But that magnanimity doesn’t go both ways: Vaccinated people “look at you” differently if you decide not to get the shots, she said.

“Why do you care what I’m doing if you feel protected?’” Ms. Pasqualucci said. “If I don’t want to take that extra step to protect myself, how does that affect you?”

Advertise with us
Dr. Amy Crawford-Faucher, a family physician in Monroeville and the vice chair of family medicine at Allegheny Health Network (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

As a family physician in Monroeville, Dr. Amy Crawford-Faucher said she’s not surprised when some of her younger patients tell her they do not want the vaccine.

“Overarching, it is probably a fairly consistent sense of immortality. ‘I know I am at low risk of severe COVID disease if I’m in this age range,’ which is honestly mostly true,” she said. “Or, ‘I already got COVID, and it really wasn’t that bad and I think I’m covered.’”

While young people may believe it isn’t urgent for them to get vaccinated, Dr. Crawford-Faucher, who also is vice chair of family medicine at Allegheny Health Network, cited three reasons why she believes it’s “incredibly important.”

One, it protects more vulnerable members of society, including the elderly and the immunocompromised, for whom the vaccine might not be as effective.

Two, it reduces the number of people spreading the virus, limiting opportunities for it to mutate and create new variants.

Advertise with us

Last week, the highly contagious delta variant was the most dominant coronavirus strain in the U.S. Public health officials warned that it poses a severe risk to unvaccinated people, as COVID-19 hospitalizations spiked and Pfizer indicated it wants people to get a third dose of its shot for greater protection.

And three, Dr. Crawford-Faucher says, young people should get vaccinated to protect themselves from becoming “long haulers,” the roughly 10% of people who contract COVID-19 and suffer long-term symptoms.

“‘I know you’re probably not going to end up in the hospital when you get COVID,’” Dr. Crawford-Faucher tells her patients. “‘But you may have the loss of smell for six months or permanently. And that’s really, really distressing. Or you might have fatigue for six months, and that is going to mess up your new job or your college career.’”

Combating misinformation with education

As young people spent endless hours scrolling through TikTok, Instagram and Facebook while quarantining during the past year, inaccurate information about the vaccine spread on social media.

Advertise with us

Boundaries between news sites and social media platforms have blurred, said Dr. Crawford-Faucher, explaining that a patient had shown her a Facebook post claiming that a woman turned magnetic a month after being vaccinated.

Instead of dismissing her patient’s fears, Dr. Crawford-Faucher said it was critical that she treat her with respect.

“It’s my job to make a connection with someone,” she said. “If you look at anybody, a patient of any age, and go, ‘Well, that’s just stupid,’ you’re not going to make that connection. You’re going to just turn them off from the health system and from further contemplation.”

Dr. Elizabeth Miller, director of the Division of Adolescent and Young Adult Medicine at UPMC Children’s Hospital, said public health officers should make it a priority to equip young people with accurate information.

“It’s so important that we not just lump all the teens together and say, ‘Oh, they’re just being swayed by social media,’” Dr. Miller said. “Actually, young people are incredibly insightful and incredibly thoughtful with their questions. It so much has to do with limited access to good, accurate information.”

Advertise with us

Education policy adviser Kaitlyn Brennan works to get accurate vaccine information to young people.

Listening to young people and parents to better understand their attitudes toward the vaccine, she said she sees firsthand how social media — TikTok in particular — fuels the reluctance of many young people to get vaccinated.

She works with the Pittsburgh Community Vaccine Collaborative, an initiative aimed at mitigating the disproportionate impact of the coronavirus among minority communities. In June, the collaborative surveyed young people to learn why they chose to get vaccinated and to gauge the concerns of their family members and peers in regard to the vaccine.

The survey results will guide a campaign to increase vaccine uptake among people between 12 and 20 years old. It will use social media and webinars to provide accurate vaccine information. In addition, the collaborative will hold workshops to teach people “how to differentiate social media myths from truth.”

Eighteen-year old Kemontrell King of Brighton Heights said he takes what he reads on the internet with a grain of salt. But he said his mom is skeptical about the vaccine because of information she reads online — one reason why he, his parents and four siblings between the ages of 8 and 15 are not vaccinated.

Advertise with us

“Anybody could put anything on the internet and change it to something. Like it could be true, but at the same time, it’s most likely fake,” he said. “That’s what the internet does.”

Mr. King said he’s “been busy” but plans to get vaccinated before starting at Community College of Allegheny County in the fall.

Dr. Crawford-Faucher encourages people like Mr. King who are trying to navigate a flurry of information about the vaccine to seek out a variety of sources.

“The key thing is, look for information that’s outside your normal channels,” she advised. “If they go to trusted people, whether they are teachers, or co-workers, or religious leaders or, gosh darn it, their family doctor — reach out and just ask the questions.”

Ema R. Schumer: eschumer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @emaschumer.