Over a month has passed since an internal police report investigating the death of Jim Rogers was leaked to the media.

Today, the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office said its request to view that report was denied by a Court of Common Pleas judge, dealing a setback to the county’s highest legal authority as it determines whether to file criminal charges against officers who Tased the 54-year-old Black man last year.

“This is a prime example of the hurdles that are faced when conducting an investigation, and we respectfully disagree with the judges decision,” said Mike Manko, a spokesman for District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala.

According to court records, the DA’s office filed a request on Dec. 22 for the 15-page summary report, conducted by the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police’s Critical Incident Review Board.

Advertise with us

“Such a document would be enormously valuable in order to further conduct an exhaustive investigation,” the office wrote in its request.

On Jan. 11, the DA’s office was notified by Judge Jill E. Rangos, the administrative judge of the criminal division, that its request was denied.

Within that report are crucial details of the events that led to Mr. Roger’s death on Oct. 13, when police were called to Bloomfield by neighbors who reported that Mr. Rogers was allegedly stealing a bicycle that was listed for sale on a lawn and trespassing on a porch.

During the incident, a Pittsburgh Police officer used a Taser on Mr. Rogers multiple times. Despite witnesses saying Mr. Rogers was not aggressive during the incident, police insisted he was noncompliant.

Mr. Rogers was taken to a local hospital by officers and pronounced dead on Oct. 14.

Advertise with us

While the Bureau of Police did not release its investigation publicly, the then-Mayor Bill Peduto’s office announced on Dec. 21 that nine officers involved, including two supervisors, would face disciplinary action, citing a “series of procedural failures.”

The result of those actions and the names and positions of the officers were not revealed.

The District Attorney previously said he would wait until the Medical Examiner’s office revealed the official cause of Mr. Rogers’ death before considering whether to bring criminal charges against the officers.

On Jan. 3, Medical Examiner Karl Williams said the death was “accidental,” due to reduced oxygen to the brain. That instance is commonly the result of cardiac arrest.

“Dr. Williams has always been objective in his medical analysis,” Mr. Manko said on behalf of the DA’s office that day. “It is obvious that Mr. Rogers' interaction with the police is central to a determination of criminal culpability in connection with the cause of death. As is usual, such a determination will require further scrutiny and explanation by Dr. Williams and his office."

Jesse Bunch: jbunch@post-gazette.com