“Herd immunity” holds that as long as a large majority of a group is vaccinated or inoculated, even the unimmunized minority will mostly be protected.

It’s a concept that applies to control and containment of a host of human diseases like polio, measles, mumps and rubella, but not usually invasive insect pests like the emerald ash borer.

Until now.

A multiyear, multi-agency, experimental field study underway in the Allegheny National Forest is seeking to determine how fast the ash borer is moving through the forest and how many ash trees in a stand must be treated with insecticide to save the stand.

Advertise with us

Positive findings from the four-year study, funded with a $67,000 grant from the U.S. Forest Service’s State and Private Forestry branch, have the potential to help forest managers save more of the trees in the 32 states where the ash borer has been found so far.

“Herd immunity is the unique thing we’re looking at in this study. We are trying to determine if we treat a bunch of the trees in a certain area, do the untreated trees also get protection,” said Kathleen Knight, a U.S. Forest Service research ecologist and a project leader.

The shiny green Asian beetle first arrived in North America in Detroit in 2002, as an accidental stowaway in shipping materials. Since then it has killed hundreds of millions of the 8.7 billion ash trees in the U.S., spreading rapidly into 32 states and southern Canada.

It has the potential to transform the hardwood forests of North America to an extent not seen since the fungal chestnut blight arrived from Asia in 1904 and wiped out the 4 billion American chestnut trees from the nation’s eastern forests by the 1950s.

The borer was first found in Pennsylvania, where most of the best baseball bat-grade ash grows, in 2007. The state’s forests contain approximately 308 million ash trees, only about 7 percent of the forest acreage overall but up to 50 percent in several northern tier counties.

Advertise with us

In Pittsburgh, the bug killed most of the 180,000 ash trees in city parks by the fall of 2016.

The ash borer found its way to the Allegheny National Forest and its more than 20 million ash trees in 2013.

Signs of infestation by the bright green, half-inch-long borers — Agrilus planipennis — include dead branches at the top of the tree, yellow leaves, woodpecker holes, D-shaped holes in the tree bark and curvy trails made by larvae under the bark. Almost all ash die within two to three years after the bugs arrive.

Ms. Knight said the new herd immunity research is treating various percentages of the ash on 193 tree plots of various sizes. The plots were first laid out by Forest Service researchers in 2010 to provide baseline data on ash health before the borer invasion.

In each of those plots, pesticides were applied to different numbers and percentages of the ash trees in 2015. The researchers checked the tree health in 2017 and are reapplying the insecticide this spring.

Advertise with us

“Over the next three years we should get a good handle on if we are seeing herd immunity, whether it works or it doesn’t, and if it does, at what level of treatment,” Ms. Knight said.

She said it’s expensive to treat ash with pesticides and the treatment must be repeated every three years, so if foresters can save the trees by treating 80 percent, for example, they can save 20 percent of the costs.

“We don’t know how high the treatment percentage needs to be, but if 20 percent don’t need to be treated, that cost savings can be huge if we’re talking about treating thousands of ash trees.”

Andrea Hille, a silviculturist, or forest cultivator, for the Allegheny National Forest, said the forest service recently paid a private contractor $54,000 to apply pesticide to 471 ash trees, mostly in clusters of at least 20 trees.

“We tried to target the healthy ash with the pesticide, and my hope as a land manager on the ANF is that we can sustain clusters of healthy ash trees that will provide genetic diversity and over time lead to the successful regeneration of ash,” Ms. Hille said. “But we really don’t know what will happen to the emerald ash borer after it sweeps through the forest. If our ash can’t be saved, maybe this research can help other forests survive.”

Advertise with us

The new federal grant money has allowed the project to expand its monitoring work to include a new student contingent from Washington & Jefferson College.

Jason Kilgore, a forest ecology associate professor at W&J, said starting next month one student will be partnering with forest service researchers to monitor not only the ash in the forest plots but also what kind of plants are growing in the understory, below the trees. Next summer, two more students will join the project and be trained by the first.

“The students will get real world experience working with the forest service.” Mr. Kilgore said. “And that real world research can have an impact.”

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey.