Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court has affirmed a zoning ordinance in Allegheny Township that allows Marcellus Shale gas drilling anywhere in the semi-rural Westmoreland County municipality.

The ruling, handed down by the court Friday, is a legal setback for residents seeking to battle shale gas development by invoking the state’s 1971 Environmental Rights Amendment.

Commonwealth Court, in a 5-2 decision, ruled that the township’s non-restrictive, 2010 zoning law, which allows oil and gas drilling in all zoning districts, is valid, and that several State Supreme Court decisions requiring local governments to enforce the amendment’s public health, safety and welfare protections do not apply.

President Judge Mary Hannah Leavitt wrote in a 41-page opinion that concerns the well drilling and hydraulic fracturing would cause safety or environmental problems “were not supported by evidence” and that permit conditions mitigate those risks.

Advertise with us

The case challenging the township’s zoning law was prompted by the municipality’s October 2014 approval of a CNX Gas Co. shale gas well on farmland near properties owned by Dolores Frederick and two neighbors.

All the properties involved are zoned “R-2,” with established uses of agriculture, low-density developments and individual housing.

The appellants challenged the validity of the zoning ordinance, arguing that an unconventional gas well is not a land use compatible with agricultural-residential use, and also appealed the state permit issued to the Consol Energy subsidiary for the planned Porter Pad, which will eventually hold six wells.

Attorney Christopher Papa, who represents Ms. Frederick and neighbors Patricia Hagaman and Beverly Taylor, said he and his clients were disappointed by the court decision but were encouraged by the two dissenting opinions that embraced his arguments about the applicability of the Environmental Rights Amendment to the case.

“Those [dissents] showed we were on to something, that we are not crazy,” Mr. Papa said. “It shows the argument we have been making for four years now is very logical, and putting an industrial use in a residential area is not.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Papa said he would meet with his clients later this week to discuss the verdict and likely would appeal to the state Supreme Court.

In her dissenting opinion, Judge Ellen Ceisler said the state’s Environmental Rights Amendment imposes an “affirmative duty” on the township to ensure that both publicly and privately owned resources are protected.  And Judge Patricia McCullough, in her dissent, said the case should be sent back to the township zoning board to provide evidence why it’s ordinance allows drilling in all township zones, a provision she termed “an extreme measure.”

Township attorney Bernard Matthews Jr. said the court’s majority opinion recognized that the municipality has no obligation to have any zoning ordinance or to regulate oil and gas development.

“The township is a rural residential community with a lot of agricultural property we can preserve if the owners are able to lease and develop their subsurface oil and gas mineral rights,” Mr. Matthews said. “Allowing this well doesn’t harm agriculture, but rather will allow us to try to preserve agricultural use.”

About 12,500 acres of the township’s approximately 20,000 acres is leased to various shale gas development companies, as is 75 percent of the township land zoned R-2.

Advertise with us

There are already 242 older, conventional gas wells drilled in the township. The well on the Porter Pad would be the first unconventional well, which would be drilled deeper and then horizontally in the Marcellus Shale formation.

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey