A Westmoreland County judge likely will decide early next year whether a teenager can plead guilty but mentally ill to charges that he slashed and stabbed 20 fellow students and a security guard at Franklin Regional High School in Murrysville.
If Common Pleas Judge Christopher Feliciani allows Alex Hribal, 19, of Murrysville, to plead guilty but mentally ill, Mr. Hribal will go first to a mental health facility and then, if his condition improves, to a state prison to complete his sentence. If the judge rejects Mr. Hribal’s request, defense attorney Patrick Thomassey said he intends to take the case before a jury.
“I don’t understand what we’re doing here,” Mr. Thomassey said Monday, noting that a guilty but mentally ill plea wouldn’t prevent his client from serving a sentence.
Westmoreland County District Attorney John Peck said he hadn’t seen evidence that Mr. Hribal’s mental conditions couldn’t be adequately treated in a state prison and that, based on the severity of the crimes, he didn’t want to do a disservice to the victims.
Mr. Thomassey and Mr. Peck spoke after a nearly three-hour hearing Monday at which four mental health professionals testified about their interactions with Mr. Hribal since the stabbings April 9, 2014. After a transcript of the hearing is complete, both sides can submit written arguments, and then Judge Feliciani will rule whether Mr. Hribal should be allowed to plead guilty but mentally ill.
Three defense witnesses said they thought Mr. Hribal’s mental illnesses prevented him from being able to comprehend the gravity of his actions and from being able to stop his plan to stab fellow students. The lone prosecution witness, Bruce Wright, a psychiatrist, said he thought Mr. Hribal would have been capable of stopping himself had he wanted to.
The witnesses’ diagnoses of Mr. Hribal varied over time, as they had more interviews with him, and sometimes with each other. They agreed that Mr. Hribal had some form of depression. The defense experts argued that Mr. Hribal had psychotic thoughts at the time of the stabbings — thoughts that, according to Mr. Hribal’s statements — cleared up when he was stopped by an assistant principal and arrested.
Dr. Wright said he wasn’t convinced. He pointed to lines in a letter Mr. Hribal wrote in the days before the stabbings and placed inside his locker. He talks about being a “prophet” of the Columbine High School shooters, who killed 13 people and wounded many others in a shooting at a Colorado high school. He also refers to the stabbings as a crime.
“I think that shows that he knew what he was doing was wrong,” Dr. Wright said, adding that never in his nearly 25-year career had he seen someone snap out of a psychotic thought process almost instantaneously.
But multiple defense experts, each of whom has been working in their fields for at least 30 years, testified that it was possible. Dr. Christine Martone, who runs behavioral evaluations for the Allegheny County court system, testified that the same letter Dr. Wright referred to was so disorganized and full of contradictions that it could also serve as evidence that Mr. Hribal was psychotic. According to testimony from various witnesses, Mr. Hribal said he experienced depression in elementary school that became more tolerable for a bit in middle school and then intensified in high school. They said he attempted to kill himself once with a knife but decided not to do it. They said he performed well in school, behaved appropriately in classes and was quiet, often keeping to himself. Mr. Hribal told at least one expert witness that he thought about committing direct or indirect suicide, such as a “suicide by cop.”
Alan Axelson, a child and adolescent psychiatrist who has met with Mr. Hribal more than any of the other experts, said he didn’t think Mr. Hribal was “able to really appreciate the consequences of his actions on others” at the time of the stabbings.
“Unfortunately,” Dr. Axelson said, “because of his isolation and inability to communicate, he was left inside his own head.”
Liz Navratil: lnavratil@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1438 or on Twitter @LizNavratil.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.