The attorney for the teenager charged in the Franklin Regional High School knife attack asked a judge to move the case to juvenile court, change the location for his trial and suppress key evidence.
In a broad pretrial motion filed Friday, defense attorney Patrick Thomassey argued that an “incessant barrage” of news coverage would prevent 17-year-old Alex Hribal from getting a fair trial in Westmoreland County. Jurors should be impaneled from elsewhere or the trial should be moved outside the county, he wrote.
“The coverage has been prejudicial to Hribal because it has painted him with a broad brush comparing him to the Columbine shooting defendants and other notorious actors who chose to commit violent acts at schools.”
The teen is accused of stabbing or slashing 20 students and a security guard with two kitchen knives at the Murrysville school on April 9, 2014. Mental health experts for the defense testified at a hearing last year that the teen was motivated by the 1999 Columbine school shootings in Colorado and expected to die while carrying out the Franklin Regional attack.
District Attorney John Peck said, in his experience, wide exposure has not made seating a jury problematic, noting the trials for the so-called “Greensburg Six” charged in the 2010 torture-murder of a mentally disabled woman.
“We had absolutely no difficultly in selecting jurors, despite the fact that the case caused enormous publicity and discussions among people here in Westmoreland County” and in surrounding counties, he said.
Read More
Alex was charged as an adult with 21 counts each of attempted homicide and aggravated assault.
Mr. Thomassey also argued that investigators did not have probable cause to search Alex’s school locker, home or cell phone, and any evidence they collected should not be allowed at trial. Mr. Peck disagreed, adding that the searches were properly authorized by a judge.
In arguing to move the case out of adult court, Mr. Thomassey wrote that the teen is amenable to treatment and had no prior record. The programs and services at Westmoreland County juvenile detention center — where he is receiving mental health treatment — have had a “positive effect.”
If the transfer is granted and the teen were found responsible for the crimes, he could be confined only until he is 21. Mr. Peck maintains the teen should be tried as an adult.
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.