State Sen. Robert Regola III yesterday was criminally charged in connection with the suicide of a 14-year-old next-door neighbor who shot himself with the senator's 9 mm pistol in July.

Mr. Regola, 44, a Republican from Hempfield, is accused of lying under oath about the gun's location and access in testimony during a two-day coroner's inquest last month into the death of Louis A.J. Farrell, who would have turned 15 today.

Carolyn Kaster, Associated Press

State Sen. Robert Regola III, R-Hempfield, walks through the Capitol in Harrisburg yesterday.

Advertise with us

Click photo for larger image.

The charges allege that Mr. Regola was criminally liable because he allowed his minor son Robert "Bobby" Regola IV, now 17, and Louis to have access to the gun eventually used in Louis' suicide.

In his inquest findings, hearing examiner Thomas Farrell -- no relation to the victim -- said the evidence indicated Louis committed suicide. Coroner Kenneth Bacha agreed and so ruled.

Louis' body was found by his father the morning of July 22 in the woods behind the family home. Next to him was Mr. Regola's 9 mm Taurus pistol. In the hours on July 21 before his death, Louis had access to the Regola home because he was dog-sitting for the senator, who was out of town.

The first-term senator is expected to be arraigned this morning before District Judge James Albert, in whose Greensburg office state Trooper John Zalich filed the charges yesterday. They include four felonies -- three counts of perjury and one count of allowing possession of a firearm by a minor -- and two misdemeanors, false swearing and reckless endangerment.

Advertise with us

District Attorney John W. Peck, who approved filing of the charges, had no comment yesterday but is expected to be present at a news conference today at noon at the state police station in Greensburg.

Jon Perry, the Farrells' attorney, said the family welcomed the charges.

"The family does, however, still have serious questions as to what happened in the woods that evening, and we don't believe that answer will ever be given unless and until Bobby Regola talks," Mr. Perry said.

Bobby Regola did not testify at the inquest, invoking his constitutional right against self-incrimination. According to the Regola family and testimony at the inquest, Bobby returned home on July 21 at 10:40 p.m. after a day at Idlewild Park with his girlfriend. There he found a door ajar, the refrigerator door opened and the gun missing. He called his father, who was at a function in Harrisburg, and told him what had happened.

KDKA-TV 2

Advertise with us

Louis Farrell in an undated photo.

Mr. Regola asked his brother, Ronald, who lives on the same street, to check the house but he found nothing amiss and left.

Later, Bobby was the last person known to have spoken to his friend Louis in a five-minute phone call that began at 11:01 p.m. In a statement to state police, Bobby, 16 at the time, said Louis asked him in that phone call to meet him outside; he said he asked Louis to call him back when he was ready, but Louis never did so.

"The senator has not been cooperative, has now been determined to not be truthful, and the son took the Fifth Amendment. What are they hiding?" Mr. Perry said. "What really happened in the woods back there?

"If this was a simple suicide, as it's been concluded, then that would have been the end of the story."

Advertise with us

Neither Mr. Regola, who was on the Senate floor in Harrisburg yesterday, nor his attorney, Charles J. Porter, could be reached for comment. However, following the inquest at which Mr. Peck said he was exploring the filing of charges, Mr. Porter was adamant that such action would be a mistake.

"This is a horrible tragedy but that doesn't mean ... there needs to be criminal prosecution," Mr. Porter said then. "We have civil courts to deal with tragedies. This is not a case where there should be any criminal charges."

Mr. Perry said yesterday that he had advised the Farrells to file a civil suit but they had not yet done so.

At the time of the coroner's inquest, Bobby's attorney, Duke George, said the decision to not testify should not be construed as an admission of guilt. Bobby had cooperated with investigators initially, and Mr. George said he did not want to open his client to repetitive questioning in a format where he was not allowed to object or cross-examine.

The Farrell family continues to maintain that Louis' death was not suicide despite Mr. Farrell's findings and Mr. Bacha's ruling. Mr. Perry said he remains convinced that Louis was not alone when he died, likely from an accident.

Advertise with us

"I think there's a strong possibility you had two kids back in the woods acting like kids and that's the exact reason we have statutes in Pennsylvania that kids shouldn't have guns, because bad things like this can happen," Mr. Perry said.

Mr. Perry spoke yesterday morning with Louis' father, J. Douglas Farrell, about the district attorney's decision.

"He was pleased that charges have been brought and he continues to believe, as do I, that this is an evolving story," Mr. Perry said. He added that it was difficult for the Farrells to continue living next door to the Regolas.

Trooper Zalich, the case's lead investigator, declined to say whether anyone besides the senator would be charged.

During the inquest, the senator testified that the handgun found next to Louis was never stored at any time in his son's bedroom, despite testimony from Louis' best friend that both boys had seen the gun in Bobby's bedroom within the past year or so. Mr. Regola, who campaigned for the Senate on a gun-rights platform, did say that his son kept a replica 9 mm pellet gun.

Advertise with us

A state police trooper testified, however, that Mr. Regola told him he transferred the real firearm from his son's room to his own early last summer.

Trooper Jarred Slater said that on the morning Louis Farrell was found, he asked Mr. Regola where he kept his 9 mm gun.

Trooper Slater said Mr. Regola acknowledged that he kept the pistol in his son's bedroom, but that he moved it because of concerns about possible vagrants in the woods near the house after one was seen in the neighborhood.

Mr. Farrell, the hearing examiner, wrote in his findings that the testimony of Mr. Regola was implausible with regard to where the gun was stored. He said he believed the testimony of Trooper Zalich and two friends of Louis more than that of the senator.

"The story of moving the gun to the senator's bedroom because of the concern about 'vagrants' in the woods (the story the senator told Trooper Zalich) or moving the gun from the office to the senator's home (the story the senator and his brother told on the witness stand) is incredible," Mr. Farrell wrote.

Advertise with us

"Despite his fear, he left his son home alone. Despite his fear, he rarely armed his house alarm and did not insist that his son do so on the day he was left alone. Despite his fear, when he heard from his son that an intruder had entered the house and taken a gun, he and his brother left Bobby alone in the house and did not call the police.

"It is more likely that the senator and his brother used the vagrant boy to concoct a story and bolster the false statement that he moved the gun into his bedroom."

While Mr. Regola is a pro-gun rights legislator, Louis Farrell's parents are vehemently anti-gun and implored their children to stay away from guns.

According to both Mr. Regola's Web site and his Senate profile on the Legislature's Web site, he is a member of the Police Rod and Gun Club and the National Rifle Association.

"This tragedy should not be misrepresented and exploited by anti-gun advocates," Mr. Regola said on Sept. 19 in his first public statement about the state police investigation.

Advertise with us

At that time, he said despite "reckless speculation" about the gun, the weapon was "stored in a case in my upstairs bedroom. It was not loaded and was not easily accessible, as I have young children at home."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.