Court papers unsealed yesterday reveal that investigators found the son of a state senator "deceptive" when he was questioned about the shooting death of a neighbor.
It remained unclear yesterday, however, whether Pennsylvania State Police consider 16-year-old Robert Regola IV a suspect, a witness, an accomplice or an uninvolved party in the shooting death of his next-door neighbor, Louis Farrell.
A search warrant application and affidavit filed in August but made public yesterday showed that investigators were seeking bloody clothing, among other items, from the home of Robert's father, state Sen. Robert Regola III, R-Hempfield.
State police believe that blood from the head wound that killed 14-year-old Louis behind his Hempfield home might have splattered on the shooter's clothing or shoes, according to the affidavit.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette has been seeking to have the warrant unsealed, and state Superior Court ruled Tuesday the documents should be public. They were unsealed yesterday.
Louis' body was found July 22 with a handgun next to him that was registered to Mr. Regola. The teenager had been dog-sitting for the senator the night before while Mr. Regola was out of town.
Westmoreland County District Attorney John Peck, who had fought making the search warrant information public, declined to elaborate on the affidavit yesterday, citing a need to maintain the integrity of the investigation.
He said it has not been determined yet whether Louis' death was accidental, suicide or homicide, and he would not say whether testing indicated that the gun found next to the boy was the same one that fired the fatal shot.
"There are just unanswered questions that appear to be very difficult to answer," Mr. Peck said yesterday. He added that a meeting on the case is pending between his office, state police and the coroner.
The investigating trooper said the senator's son seemed to know Louis was dead before anyone had informed him of his death.
On the morning of July 22, Louis' father, attorney J. Douglas Farrell, discovered his son's body and called 911. He soon went to the Regola home and spoke to Robert IV, known as Bobby, the affidavit said.
When Mr. Farrell asked Robert IV whether he owned a gun, the affidavit says the teen replied, "Well, jeez [sic], Mr. Farrell. The strangest thing happened last night. My gun is missing."
At 8:47 a.m., shortly after the visit from Mr. Farrell, Robert IV called his girlfriend, Anna Bevington, and told her Louis was dead, the affidavit states. But, it continues, Mr. Farrell said he never told Robert IV that Louis was dead.
That point is one of several made in the affidavit by Trooper John Zalich, the lead investigator, to back up his contention that Robert IV's statement to police "lacked detail and seemed somewhat deceptive because he left out several key factors. I had to obtain a lot of information from his girlfriend."
Trooper Zalich noted that Robert IV called his girlfriend at 11:35 p.m. the night before Louis died to tell her "his gun" was missing. He also mentioned the missing gun to his uncle, Mr. Regola's brother, Ronald, who lives several houses away on Glenmeade Road, when he stopped by late that night to check on his nephew.
State police characterized Robert IV's discussion with his uncle about the gun missing from the master bedroom as "last minute."
"The gun never gets reported stolen or does anybody go out of their way to determine where the gun was at," Trooper Zalich wrote.
Attorney Duke George, who is representing Robert IV, declined comment and said attorney Mark Rush, who represents Mr. Regola, would speak for both of them.
Mr. Rush disputed many of the allegations in the affidavit, most importantly the notion that Robert IV had not been told that Louis, his friend, was dead when he notified his girlfriend.
Mr. Rush said that information was supplied by Mr. Farrell. He stopped short of calling Mr. Farrell a liar, but said that in his distraught state, Mr. Farrell might not have had a clear recollection of the conversation.
Mr. Rush also said that police needed information that cast suspicion on Robert IV in order to get the search warrant.
"We absolutely disagree with the trooper's assertion that Bobby was not advised of the death that morning," Mr. Rush said. "There was a conversation about the gun and there was a conversation about Louis being dead."
He said Mr. Farrell told Robert IV that Louis had been shot and demanded to know if the youth owned a black gun. Mr. Rush said Robert IV answered that he didn't have a black gun, but he said the family did have a silver gun with a black handle and it was missing.
State police interviewed Mr. Regola on July 22, and the senator "made the statement that he knows the gun was his and that he feels bad and can't believe Lou shot himself. At no point during the investigation was Regola III told that the gun used in the shooting was his nor was the weapon described to him in any manner."
Mr. Regola has said that both he and his son are blameless in their neighbor's death.
The search warrant application filed Aug. 8 said troopers wanted to search the Regola home for any clothing containing blood, Philly cigars, Winchester 9 mm shells, and computer hardware and software.
It does not say what, if anything, was seized.
It says a handgun, a pink flashlight and a Philly cigar were found near the body.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.