The Montour School District is paying for decisions made by its former superintendent.

An arbitrator last month ordered the district to pay $170,866 in bad-faith penalties to plumbing contractor SSM Industries after determining that former superintendent Donald Boyer, who retired in 2015, failed to pay the company for some of its work on the high school building, solicitor Ira Weiss said. Mr. Boyer failed to get board approval for several SSM change orders, and when the case was taken to arbitration in 2013, Mr. Boyer also did not inform the board about the possibility of a settlement that could have saved the district more than $300,000.

“What you have here is someone who operated in a completely opaque fashion, often contrary to the letter and spirit of state regulations and strictly for the purposes of control,” Mr. Weiss said.

In addition to the penalties, the arbitrator ordered the school district to pay about $410,662 for some work SSM did during a $47 million renovation to Montour High School, as well as $61,599 in interest and $106,679 in attorney fees and arbitration costs.

Advertise with us

Mr. Boyer instructed all staff members and consultants involved with SSM’s work to deal only with him, Mr. Weiss said. As a result, the school board had no direct contact with the company. Board members had some idea of the work SSM did on the high school building but were not aware of the discussions Mr. Boyer had with the company separately from the board, Mr. Weiss said.

The school board agreed to make the payments at its meeting last week.

Mr. Boyer could not be reached for comment.

Mr. Boyer came out of retirement and was named Montour's superintendent in September 2010. The board placed Mr. Boyer on administrative leave in January 2015, pending his retirement two months later. Around the same time, a report commissioned by the district found that he allowed — without board approval — the former director of special education to take a job at Duquesne University at the same time she was still employed by the Montour district. The report also found that Mr. Boyer, without board approval, offered the Montour Education Association a new health insurance retirement incentive that called for retirees to receive health care for 10 years past retirement, including coverage for dependents.

Board president Tom Barclay said members were “led astray” by Mr. Boyer. The district recently raised taxes, and a large portion of that money will be used to pay the penalties and legal bills.

Advertise with us

“Do we have to take some of the blame? I think we do,” he said. “But you want to think that the people that you place in charge and have been doing it for years will do the right thing.”

The district is now scrutinizing all of the contracts written while Mr. Boyer was superintendent, board member Darrell Young said. He said he is disappointed that the roughly $780,000 generated by last year’s tax increase is now “basically a wash.”

“To have a bad-faith judgment against the district, it’s embarrassing,” he said.

Elizabeth Behrman: 412-263-1590 or Lbehrman@post-gazette.com.