YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio — When an explosion awoke Jean McCammon shortly before 4 a.m. Monday and she saw flames shooting from a house across the street, she knew almost immediately that no one inside had survived.
Neighbors quickly realized they had a tragedy on their street: Two deaf adults and their 10-year-old granddaughter were dead. Youngstown and Mahoning County officials had not released their identities as of late Monday.
It grew more heartbreaking, neighbors said, when they learned that the girl had been the victim in a rape case and the suspect, her mother’s boyfriend, was scheduled to go to trial Monday morning.
The cause of the fire on Powers Way remained under investigation. Youngstown police Capt. Brad Blackburn said early indications were that it wasn’t suspicious, but that was not the final determination.
The girl’s death prompted a pause in the rape case against Robert Seman, 46, whose bond was revoked Monday, but not because of the fire. Rather, someone had contacted police, claiming he had tried to bribe a witness to say the girl had lied.
With the victim dead, Mahoning County prosecutor Paul Gains said his office was reviewing the case to see whether it could proceed. He declined to say whether prosecutors had recorded a statement from the girl.
Read More
While detectives searched through the charred, green house, neighbors talked about the victims and hoped they had not suffered.
“It’s a tragedy,” Ms. McCammon said. “I pray to God that they didn’t burn.”
A quiet neighborhood
Powers Way is lined with midsize family homes. Neighbors walk up and down the street without fear. Many keep to themselves. Some stop to chat.
Ms. McCammon, 82, moved in about 10 years ago and communicated, often via pencil and paper, with the deaf couple across the street. The man had worked for AT&T, and the woman at one point did some work at a school for the hearing-impaired.
The couple had planned to eventually move to a cabin in Pennsylvania, where the man liked to hunt and fish, said longtime friend Ricky Bloom, who used American Sign Language as the male victim’s sister interpreted for reporters.
In recent years, the couple’s blond granddaughter had moved in. She was a fourth-grader at nearby South Range Elementary School, whose principal, Steve Matos, described her as a “wonderful student.”
“She went to school here since kindergarten. She was well-known and loved here by everyone on staff. [She was] a bright girl, [had] lots of friends,” Mr. Matos said.
To some in the neighborhood, they were “the perfect family,” Ms. McCammon said.
A rape case
Unbeknownst to some in the neighborhood, Mr. Seman had been charged with raping the girl.
Goshen, Ohio, police Lt. Nicholas Brent said the girl’s mother contacted officers there March 10, 2014, and told them Mr. Seman had sexually assaulted her child multiple times. Police obtained a warrant for Mr. Seman’s arrest. He surrendered five days later and was placed in the Mahoning County Jail.
A grand jury indicted Mr. Seman on four counts of rape and four counts of gross sexual imposition, saying the assaults began in January 2009, when the girl was 4, and continued through October 2013, when she was 8.
Mr. Seman was eventually released on bail and placed on house arrest, which he served first at his parents’ home and then at his own, officials said.
His attorney, Tom Zena, said Mr. Seman was under electronic monitoring when the fire began, and a check of his system showed no violations Monday morning.
Judge Maureen Sweeney of Mahoning County Common Pleas Court revoked Mr. Seman’s bond in light of the bribery allegation reported to police. Mr. Zena said he learned of the woman’s statements for the first time in court Monday.
A fatal fire
Ms. McCammon was in bed when she heard what sounded like an explosion. Her mother taught her, “If you ever see anything unusual or hear anything unusual, just mark the time.”
It was 3:41 a.m.
She put on warm clothes and went downstairs. “The whole house was a ball of fire,” she said.
Youngstown firefighters arrived within minutes, Chief John O’Neill said, and found the house engulfed in flames.
Neighbors initially told officials that they thought five people, including an infant, were inside. When firefighters went in, the floors were already starting to buckle. They worried when they reached a room with a crib and didn’t see a baby.
Around them, parts of the home began to collapse. A captain fell through a floor and was taken to a hospital and was released later Monday.
Eventually, firefighters learned that a woman and an infant initially thought to be inside the home were elsewhere, Chief O’Neill said. They had the fire under control by about 5 a.m.
An arson team walked through the house Monday afternoon. Relatives, who declined to comment, stood outside, crying and signing with one another.
Early indications were that the fire began in the basement, the chief said.
The single explosion that neighbors told firefighters they heard is a common phenomenon when fires progress rapidly, Chief O’Neill said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.