Prosecutors in Ohio will seek the death penalty against a man charged with burning down the home of a 10-year-old girl he was accused of raping, killing her and her deaf grandparents.
A grand jury in Mahoning County on Thursday indicted Robert Seman Jr., 46, of Canfield, Ohio, on multiple counts of aggravated murder, aggravated arson and aggravated burglary.
The indictment accuses Mr. Seman of starting the fire March 30 that killed Corinne Gump, whom he was accused of sexually assaulting for four years, and her grandparents, William Schmidt, 63, and Judith Schmidt, 61, hours before jury selection was to begin in the rape trial.
“I’m shocked that anybody would want to do that to them, to anyone, but especially to Bill and Judy,” Steve Leland, who had known the grandparents for 25 years, said Friday.
Neighbors said the home on Powers Way in Youngstown exploded in flames early that morning. A firefighter was injured when he fell between floors.
Detectives found two 5-gallon plastic gas cans at the scene, and prosecutors said gasoline was used to start the fire.
Read More
At the time of the fire, Mr. Seman, who was dating Corinne’s mother, was free under electronic monitoring after posting a $100,000 bond in the rape case.
He also is accused of bribing a witness after his ex-wife told police he offered her $10,000 before the rape trial if she would tell officials the child had lied to police.
Five hours after officials received reports of the 3 a.m. fire, Mr. Seman went to the office of the electronic monitoring agency, asking to have his monitoring anklet replaced with a tighter one, according to a news release from Mahoning County prosecutor Paul Gains.
When officials learned of the fire and the alleged bribery, they revoked Mr. Seman’s bond and ordered him into the custody of the sheriff, Mr. Gains’ news release said. He would not comment further on Friday.
Ohio’s criminal justice system differs from Pennsylvania’s in that many cases are handled in secret by a grand jury. As a result, information about evidence and probable cause often is not revealed until the trial phase.
Last year, a grand jury indicted Mr. Seman on four counts of rape and four counts of gross sexual imposition, saying he started assaulting Corinne in January 2009, when she was 4, and continued through October 2013.
Corinne’s mother, Lynn Schmidt, could not be reached for comment.
In April, Ms. Schmidt told WFMJ-TV that she hoped “they find some proof” that Mr. Seman started the fire.
“He said that he would not kill me because he wanted me to suffer as much as he was going to suffer for going to jail,” Ms. Schmidt told the television station. “And he would make sure it was a way that we would suffer, and I guess his way was my parents and my daughter.”
The death of the three has left the community mourning.
Mr. Leland, of Salem, said Bill Schmidt, who had “one of the greatest laughs,” was an outdoors enthusiast who loved taking his three children, two of whom are deaf, camping and fishing.
“They loved being grandparents,” said Mr. Leland, manager of the Easter Seals Youngstown Hearing and Speech Center.
After Corinne’s death, the South Range Local School District, a small district of about 1,300 students, began offering counseling to its students and teachers, superintendent Dennis Dunham said.
On the last day of school Thursday, the indictment was announced as school let out, something Mr. Dunham said he was glad didn’t happen earlier, during school hours.
“That tends to bring out some of the raw emotions. ... With kids, it is kind of a domino effect,” he said of the mourning process. “The kids truly cared for Corinne.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.