After more than two years of accusations that he threatened to kill a man in his office during a tirade, Beaver County Sheriff George David left a courtroom yesterday in triumph when a jury concluded that he didn't do it.

"I'm back!" he said.

A jury deliberated about an hour Friday afternoon before finding him not guilty of charges of terroristic threats, simple assault and two counts related to intimidating one of his deputies, a key witness.

The state said the sheriff pulled his gun and threatened to kill John Paul Vranesevich, operator of the Beaver Countian website, on April 16, 2012, during a meeting in the sheriff‘‍s office in which two deputies were present.

Advertise with us

"It shows you how far a lie can go," the sheriff said as his wife, Linda, dabbed away tears and his supporters celebrated in the hallway. "It was a lie from the beginning. The jury seen it."

Previously on house arrest pending the outcome of the case, the sheriff will return to the courthouse Monday.

"We're elated to have the sheriff back on duty," said his lawyer, Lee Rothman.

Senior Deputy Attorney General Laurel Brandstetter and the two state troopers who made up the prosecution team declined comment as they left the courthouse.

The sheriff still faces a second case, a summary charge, of threatening to cut a campaign worker's hands off and eat them in a separate incident.

Advertise with us

The trial started Monday with Mr. Vranesevich and Sgt. Michael Tibolet testifying against the sheriff, both saying he pulled a gun during a profane, two-hour rant in his office. Mr. Vranesevich, who had come to talk to the sheriff for a potential story about how his department procured uniforms, said the sheriff was furious at a Beaver County Times reporter for writing stories he didn't like and at the county prothonotary with whom he had been feuding since the 2011 election.

During the meeting, Mr. Vranesevich said the sheriff grew angry at him as well for asking questions about the uniforms and threatened him with a blackjack. Later, he said, Sheriff David drew his gun, pointed it briefly at him and threatened to shoot him.

Sgt. Tibolet also testified that the sheriff drew his gun, although he said he didn't hear a threat against Mr. Vranesevich. The sergeant said he initially lied about the incident, saying nothing happened, but later said he told the truth to a grand jury and in court because his lawyer told him he could be charged if he didn't.

A second deputy who witnessed the incident, Lt. Thomas Ochs, has been charged with lying and is awaiting a preliminary hearing.

The sheriff won a battle earlier in the week when the judge threw out a charge of reckless endangerment because Ms. Brandstetter neglected to ask Sgt. Tibolet if he could tell whether Sheriff David's gun was loaded.

Advertise with us

The sheriff testified in his own defense Thursday, saying he never pulled the weapon or issued a threat against Mr. Vranesevich.

He said Mr. Vranesevich was mad at him because he felt the sheriff had not done more to help his domestic partner, Brad Davis, a police officer who had lost his job with the Ambridge department.

The sheriff said Mr. Vranesevich "agitated" him by making a comment about "bringing down an elected official" and questioning him about his wife, whom Mr. Vranesevich told him had been fired by the prothonotary, Nancy Werme, a former friend of the sheriff's who had become a political enemy.

The sheriff admitted that he grew angry and threatened to kill Ms. Werme and J.D. Prose, a Beaver County Times reporter who had written stories about his department's budget that he thought were unfair.

The state's charges, however, concerned only Mr. Vranesevich, who had formerly been friendly with the sheriff.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rothman said Mr. Vranesevich was motivated by a desire to increase traffic to his website and make a name for himself in Beaver County.

He said the people of Beaver County should "be wary" of him from now on.