Lawyers will begin questioning individual potential jurors this morning in the criminal trial of Beaver County Sheriff George David, who is accused of threatening to shoot a reporter and chop off the hands of a campaign worker.

Jury selection began Monday afternoon and is expected to finish Thursday, with the trial starting next Monday.

Sheriff David, 67, is charged with threatening to kill John Paul Vranesevich, operator of the Beaver Countian website, and threatening to cut off and eat the hands of campaign volunteer Daniel Fleischman, a county jail guard.

The sheriff's lawyer, Lee Rothman, and the prosecution team began questioning jurors as a group Monday; a pool was chosen by Tuesday afternoon.

Advertise with us

Selecting impartial jurors has been somewhat tedious because several in the jury pool know the sheriff, and nearly everyone has read or watched news accounts about the case.

One woman Tuesday morning acknowledged that she went to high school with the state trooper who led the investigation and has talked about the case with her neighbor, an assistant district attorney, but she said she could still be fair. Mr. Rothman asked that she be dismissed, but Senior Judge Francis Fornelli of Mercer County, who is presiding over the case, rejected the request.

Under further questioning later, however, the woman changed her mind, saying she couldn’t be impartial. The judge sent her home.

Sheriff David, a self-described “rough-around-the-edges” former Aliquippa police officer who once was shot in the line of duty, is charged with intimidation, assault, terroristic threats and other offenses.

State troopers arrested him in March 2013 on allegations Mr. Vranesevich and Mr. Fleischman raised.

Advertise with us

According to a state grand jury, the sheriff met with Mr. Vranesevich on April 16, 2012, to talk about purchasing contracts for uniforms and equipment. Mr. Vranesevich said the sheriff, already agitated by stories Beaver County Times reporter J.D. Prose had written about the uniforms, became increasingly irate and at one point pulled his gun and said he would kill Mr. Vranesevich if he started writing about the same issue.

Mr. Vranesevich said the sheriff took a blackjack from a drawer, slapped it down on the desk and said he would beat Mr. Prose “worse than I used to beat the [racial slur] in Aliquippa.”

Mr. Prose is expected to testify.

In the other incident, the grand jury said Mr. Fleischman, a guard at the Beaver County Jail, tried to shake Sheriff David’s hand Nov. 5, 2011, at a campaign event.

“I heard you talk about me,” the sheriff said, according to the grand jury presentment. “Shake my hand, I'll cut your [expletive] hands off, and I’ll eat them.”

Advertise with us

A deputy sheriff, Lt. Thomas Ochs, also has been charged in relation to the case. Troopers said Lt. Ochs, a witness to the Vranesevich incident who was granted immunity for his testimony, repeatedly lied about what happened to protect his boss.

Judge Fornelli said he intends to sequester the jurors after they begin deliberations and will keep them in deliberations through the weekend if necessary.