Carnegie's primary ballot has been shortened by Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge Joseph M. James, who disqualified five candidates for failing to file financial interest statements on time.
The borough deadline was 5 p.m. March 10.
Those jettisoned include Mayor Emmett Freshwater of Swallow Hill Road, who also is Democratic chairman; Councilman Fred Carini of Cubbage Street; Ray Mussill of Patterson Avenue; John Kandracs of Library Avenue; and Bridget VanDorn of Beechwood Avenue.
Mrs. VanDorn is the lone Republican.
That leaves Democrats Patrick Catena of Beechwood Avenue and Richard D'Loss of Rowland Avenue in the race for nominations for two seats in Ward 2 and Democrat Robert Veres of Huron Drive on the ballot for the Ward 1 nomination against Republican Boyd Houy of Flynn Avenue.
The mayor's job becomes a faceoff between two former mayors -- Jim Pascoe of Reamer Avenue and Tom Snyder of Huron Drive.
Just because their names won't be on the May 19 ballot doesn't mean the disqualified candidates are giving up.
The four ousted council candidates said they were considering either write-in campaigns or changing their party affiliation to independent by Aug. 3 in order to be on the November ballot.
Mr. Freshwater did not return repeated phone messages.
Mrs. VanDorn is one of those considering a write-in campaign. A first-time council candidate, she told the judge that she inadvertently missed the deadline.
But other candidates were not so accepting of the court rulings to remove their names from the primary ballot.
"I was a little discouraged [with the process]," said Mr. Kandracs, who said he was still interested in being a councilman.
So is Mr. Mussill, who expressed disappointment with the local Democratic committee's handling of the financial interest forms and who has just been named a party committee member until May 2010.
Mr. Carini, who said the Carnegie Democratic Committee would endorse the yanked candidates if they conduct write-in or independent campaigns, called their removals from the primary ballot "an egregious injustice to the citizens of Carnegie. The residents will never have their day at the poll."
Mr. Carini was upset that Judge James believed the testimony of borough Manager Stephen Vincenti, who was called into court to testify, over that of himself, Mr. Freshwater and witness Blair Clover. They said Mr. Carini handed Mr. Vincenti a folder with the candidates' financial interest statements after the March 9 Carnegie council meeting.
The trio sought a continuance to look at the council meeting videotape to see if the action was captured on camera, but Judge James wouldn't allow it.
In his testimony, Mr. Vincenti produced a time log indicating that the financial interest statements for the five candidates were not filed until after the March 10 deadline. He kept a running daily tally of when statements came in.
"I have a $6.8 million business to run for Carnegie, including 27 full-time employees, 25 miles of streets and 36 miles of sewer lines," Mr. Vincenti said. "I don't get involved in politics."
Mr. Veres, who submitted the challenge to Mr. Carini's financial interest statement filing, disputed Mr. Carini's view of the court outcome.
"We did what was right. The judge chose to believe Mr. Vincenti instead of the four [Democrats], and therefore justice and honesty prevailed."
Mr. Catena, who challenged the nomination petitions of Mr. Mussill and Mr. Kandracs, said, "I'm just glad this whole proceeding is over."
Pleased, too, with the court ruling, Mr. Snyder said: "I'm ready for the primary. Let the people speak in May."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.