Five candidates for Carnegie municipal offices could be disqualified because they failed to file financial interest disclosures with the borough by the March 10 deadline.
Challenges to the election petitions for one Carnegie mayor candidate and four borough council candidates -- including an incumbent -- were filed Tuesday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court. The challenges will be heard at 9 a.m. next Thursday in the court.
The disclosures are required by the state ethics law.
In four of the five challenges, the financial disclosure filings were made this week.
The ethics law states that failure to file financial interest disclosure forms on time is "a fatal defect" to a nomination petition and may result in disqualification.
Mayor Emmett Freshwater, who filed his financial interest statement two days ago, could not be reached for comment.
Mr. Freshwater, a former council member and Carlynton school director, is chairman of the borough Democratic Party and a state auditor. He was appointed mayor in April 2008 by Common Pleas Court.
The court got involved because of a three-mayor standoff that developed following the October 2007 resignation of former Mayor James Pascoe, of Reamer Avenue, who subsequently asked to be reinstated.
Now, Mr. Freshwater's petition to be elected is being challenged by Tom Snyder, of Huron Drive, a former council member and mayor. Mr. Snyder and Mr. Pascoe, both Democrats, have filed nomination papers for mayor.
Ward 1 council candidate Robert Veres, of Huron Drive, also a former Carlynton school director, challenged the nomination petition of Democratic Councilman Fred Carini, who submitted his candidate financial interest statement to the borough Tuesday.
Mr.Carini didn't think he had erred and argued the law is ambiguous because sitting public officials must file annual financial interest statements by May 1.
"Everything's on the up and up," he said.
Mr. Veres thought differently.
"If you don't do what you're supposed to do when you're running for office, chances are you won't be a very good council person," he said.
Democratic Ward 2 Council candidate Patrick Catena Jr., of Beechwood Avenue, who is challenging the election petitions of Democrats John Kandracs, of Library Avenue, and Ray Mussill, of Patterson Avenue, agreed.
"By not filing something as simple as a statement of financial interests, how could you put yourself forward in good conscience as a candidate?" Mr. Catena said.
Mr. Kandracs, who filed his statement Monday, said he thought the [Democratic] party was going to handle the filing.
Mr. Mussill said he wasn't aware of the March 10 deadline. He submitted his financial disclosure to the borough March 11.
"Shame on me," he said softly.
Meanwhile, a Republican who is not a candidate, filed a challenge against the Ward 2 nomination petition of Bridget VanDorn, of Beechwood Avenue, because she didn't file her financial interest statement on time.
A first-time candidate, Ms. VanDorn said, "I just didn't realize."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.