Authorities in Beaver County don't anticipate charging a homeowner whose Rottweiler-mix mauled a little girl to death on Monday night.
State Trooper Matthew Roth said the 8-year-old girl, Brianna Nicole Shanor, entered the Hanover camper where the dog was chained and died after it attacked her.
Trooper Roth said the property owner, William J. Renda, 44, had the dog properly restrained. Brianna has been living with Mr. Renda and his wife since around Jan. 6.
"The dog had the run of an old junk camper," Trooper Roth said. "She was told to stay away from the dog. No one saw this happen. But she had to have gone inside."
Troopers were conferring with the district attorney's office yesterday, but Trooper Roth said the death appears to be an accident. Beaver County Coroner Teri Tatalovich-Rossi ruled the death accidental -- though that determination has no bearing on the legal investigation -- and said last night that Brianna died from blood loss due to multiple dog bites to the neck.
The dog will likely be killed, which is typical in such cases.
"Logic dictates that you put that dog down," he said.
Like many television viewers in the community, Corey Cobbs was horrified as he watched the late news Monday night and learned of the girl's death.
"I felt so bad for that poor kid," Mr. Cobbs said.
But yesterday, while at work in the Allegheny County mailroom, he glanced at a front-page newspaper story and saw the victim's name.
Brianna, nicknamed "BriBri," was his niece.
Mr. Cobbs, 40, said he hadn't known about the death because he and his sister, Tara Sue Cobbs, 33, who is Brianna's mother, don't have much contact.
He said he didn't know why the girl, Ms. Cobbs' only child, had been living with a temporary guardian in Hanover and he had no idea where his sister was living.
No one else could shed light on that situation yesterday, either.
All was quiet at the scene of the mauling, at 181 Sutherin Road, a rural homestead near the West Virginia border where the Rendas live. Police described the Rendas as "acquaintances" of Ms. Cobb.
The home, isolated on a dirt road in farm country, is surrounded by a fence; the yard is cluttered with vehicles, small outbuildings and a child's swingset.
Reporters gathered in the driveway, but the Rendas did not emerge from the house. Their phone number is unlisted.
Troopers said Brianna had accompanied Mr. Renda outside at about 6:30 p.m. to feed his chickens. But she got cold and decided to go back to the house on her own.
Mr. Renda told police that she walked along the side of the home, where the camper rests, and out of his view. Then he noticed that the dog, which barks continually when anyone is outside, stopped barking.
When he went to investigate, police said, he found Brianna badly mauled inside the camper. He called 911, but the child was pronounced dead on arrival at Heritage Valley Beaver Hospital.
The girl's mother could not be reached.
Mr. Cobbs said he still hadn't heard from her yesterday and was struggling for an explanation.
"I don't know where to begin searching for answers," he said.
Mr. Cobbs said he last spoke with his sister earlier this month, around Jan. 6, the date that state police said Brianna began living in Hanover.
He said his sister had been evicted from a Beaver Falls home and asked to live with him. Mr. Cobbs said he couldn't oblige because he was moving from the North Side to a house in Oakmont with a friend.
"She gave me a hint that [Brianna] was staying with friends but I did not know who. I don't know what was going on in my sister's life and she would not explain it in full."
He said his sister, whom he described as "high-strung," struggled as a single mother. Brianna was the product of a relationship that ended, he said, although as far as he knew Brianna's father was involved in her life.
Ms. Cobbs was divorced, and recently a boyfriend just left her, Mr. Cobbs said.
He said a series of hardships all weighed on his sister: the latest romantic failure, the eviction, no job, no money, an unfulfilled desire to go back to school, the death of the siblings' father and the need to put their mother in a nursing home.
As for Brianna, he called her "my baby," and spoke of her in the present tense.
"She is so smart, a very artistic little girl. Very scholastic. She loves attention. My sister doesn't give her proper attention that a child that smart needs," he said. "[Brianna] kept to herself but when she did have friends she was like the captain of the team."
He said Brianna loved animals and was not afraid of dogs. She also loved his cats, one of whom he named after her.
Counselors were in place yesterday morning at South Side Elementary School in Hookstown, where Brianna went to school, to speak to students about what happened to her.
Brianna had only enrolled there on Jan. 6 and had missed several days since.
"We were really just getting to know her ourselves," said Superintendent Michael Bjalobok.
Prior to enrolling, Brianna had been a student at Central Elementary School in the Big Beaver Falls Area School District.The principal there didn't return messages yesterday.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.