Who is more of an outsider in the race for the state's 47th District Senate seat?

Is it Democrat Jason Petrella? He blasted Beaver County's Democratic machine in the primary, but lost to state Rep. Sean Ramaley -- then got appointed, over the objections of the county party committee, to fill in when Mr. Ramaley faced criminal charges and dropped out.

Or is it Elder Vogel Jr.? He is a Republican dairy farmer who said, only half-jokingly, that his best qualification for office was "not being a crook"?

The answer to that question may be the biggest key to the race in scandal-weary Beaver and Lawrence counties.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ramaley's problems -- he is charged with having a no-work job for former state Rep. Mike Veon so he could get paid while campaigning -- are just the latest smudge. The seat in contention is being vacated by Gerald LaValle, who has represented the district since 1990.

Questions were raised about Mr. LaValle's links to The Beaver Initiative for Growth, a nonproft clearing house for government grants that he founded with Mr. Veon.

In 2005 and 2006, the Initiative provided grants to the Voluntary Action Center, a nonprofit agency to help financially struggling families in Beaver County. That agency was run by Darla LaValle, Mr. LaValle's wife. Over the summer, Mrs. LaValle was charged with theft and misapplication of government property when she was accused of inflating her salary at the agency without permission of its board of directors.

"I want to restore integrity and honesty to politics in Beaver County," Mr. Vogel said. "I think people are tired of the corruption."

No one would agree with that more than Mr. Petrella. He could not be reached for comment, but in the primary, he called Mr. Ramaley a man who "owes too many favors to too many people" and said the Democratic leadership had done nothing to bring life back to towns from New Castle to the Ohio Valley.

Advertise with us

Mr. Petrella, 33, of Monaca, is a former banker who is now pursuing a doctorate in public policy at Pitt. In the primary, he offered far-reaching ideas such as equalizing property taxes statewide and offering universal health care, which he said would be better than a tax break for small businesses.

His Web site now couples property tax reform with education funding, saying the state needs to do a better job funding education so school districts don't have to rely so heavily on property taxes. He also calls on his site for tax breaks to encourage small businesses to offer health insurance.

Other issues promoted on Mr. Petrella's Web site include encouraging clean coal and other green energy technologies and pushing ethics reforms, "more accountability and transparency in the workings of government" and "less influence in the hands of lobbyists and special interest groups."

Mr. Vogel, 52, is a New Sewickley supervisor, president of the Butler-Lawrence Farm Bureau and chairman of the Pennsylvania Beef Council.

His primary focus is on lowering business taxes to bring companies back to Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

"We have great infrastructure here," he said, with rivers and rail lines as well as highways, "and a great work force. I believe taxes are what's holding us back."

Mr. Vogel also believes health care needs to be improved, particularly for older residents. He favors Legislature posting all votes, expenses and other records online for public scrutiny.

Beyond particular issues, though, he simply thinks people need to have someone they can trust in Harrisburg.

"I know what it's like to pay my own insurance," he said. "I know what it's like to deal with the rising cost of gas and diesel fuel. I know what they're going through."

And he believes people are ready to vote for real change -- even the heavily Democratic population of Beaver and Lawrence counties.

Advertise with us

"The Democratic machine has run Beaver County for the last 50 or 60 years," he said. "People are fed up with the way things are. ... They want new faces, want new ideas; they're willing to vote for someone like me.

"The same-old, same-old has gotten us nowhere."

The 47th Senate district covers most of Beaver and Lawrence counties and Crescent Township in Allegheny County.