By midnight Tuesday, Republican Charles A. Camp knew that with all polling places accounted for, he had squeaked into the third and final Beaver County commissioner's seat by 206 votes.
An hour later, with 1,183 absentee ballots tabulated, Mr. Camp's margin of victory shrank to 183 votes over fellow GOP candidate Gregory Powell. It was slim, but it was enough.
Mr. Camp acknowledged that things were tense for much of the night, enough so that he declined interviews.
"I was surprised. Everyone for the whole year has told me, 'You got it, don't worry; you got it easy, no problem,' and I always worry. I don't take things for granted," Mr. Camp, 50, of Patterson, said yesterday.
"At 1:30, I think, we found out. We were comfortable. We all started singing 'Happy Days are Here Again.' We broke out the champagne," Mr. Camp said.
Mr. Camp came in behind top vote-getter Anthony Amadio, 56, a veteran Democratic supervisor in Center, and incumbent Democratic Commissioner Joseph G. Spanik, 61, of Center.
At the bottom, but just barely, was Mr. Powell, a Rochester restaurateur whose Greg Powell's Rivertowne Restaurant granted him the name recognition that he felt propelled a solid campaign, along with his neophyte status as a fresh face to politics.
"Unbelievable," Mr. Powell said yesterday of his finish, noting that merely 11/2 more votes in each of the county's 129 precincts would have gotten him elected.
"Last night I was very upset and a little disappointed, but today I'm feeling a little bit better on what we did. Our team did an extraordinary job for a grass-roots campaign," Mr. Powell, 44, said.
He said he would not ask for a recount, because he didn't believe it would change the outcome and because he could not afford it.
Observers had different explanations for the close race. Marty Matthews, the chairman of the county's Republican committee, said he simply thought GOP voters were pushing for a Republican majority, giving both candidates a nearly equal vote.
Mr. Camp endorsed that idea.
"It wasn't me versus Greg. It was Greg and I trying to capture the majority, and because our vote totals were so close, I interpret that there were a lot of people voting for both of us that wanted to see me as the chair and us in the majority, and we just came up short," Mr. Camp said.
Richard W. Towcimak, the outgoing controller and longtime Democratic power broker, said the fact that Mr. Camp did not enjoy more of a margin of victory suggested a bit of a backlash against incumbents -- the same backlash he thinks was experienced by Mr. Spanik, who finished with 1,024 fewer votes than Mr. Amadio.
"I think there is out there an anti-incumbency feeling to a degree, and once in a while the people will take it out on an incumbent," Mr. Towcimak said. "The longer you're in there, the more enemies you make."
Mr. Towcimak also perceived fewer Democrats voting for Mr. Camp Tuesday than in the election four years ago.
"Last time Charlie enjoyed, I think, more of a crossover of some Democrats," Mr. Towcimak said. This time, "the two Republicans were left to fight it out for the Republican vote."
Mr. Camp said that as a two-term commissioner, he had been "gutsy" rather than meek and had made some unpopular decisions, which could account for his performance at the polls.
"I am a seven-year commissioner who is a gutsy commissioner. I've made decisions, I've raised taxes on occasion, I've fired people, and I've made comments and kicked people in the rear end, like [the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation] when they needed it. I have seven years of being out there and not being a shrinking violet, being out there and showing leadership," Mr. Camp said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.