Both candidates for Allegheny County Council in District 5, which covers South Fayette and part of McDonald, agree that imposing a new alcoholic drink tax to pay for transit is a bad idea.
The drink tax -- 10 percent on alcohol served in bars and restaurants in Allegheny County -- is part of a two-pronged approach to provide a dedicated funding stream of about $30 million to fund mass transit in the region.
The other source would be a $2 daily tax on car rentals.
"It seems like kind of an odd fit," said Barbara D. Logan, 71, a Mt. Lebanon commissioner who is the Democratic nominee challenging Vince Gastgeb, 44, a Republican from Bethel Park.
The two taxes heated up as an issue on Oct. 9 when Allegheny County Chief Executive Dan Onorato proposed charging them at the highest level allowed by the state Legislature.
Mr. Gastgeb has been critical of the need for new taxes. Instead, he said, the nonprofits in the region, many of which already make payments to the City of Pittsburgh, should also make payments in lieu of taxes to the county. He said another way to save money would be by consolidating city and county departments and to create public-private partnerships.
He said the city receives close to $5 million from nonprofits and since the county is three times larger, it should receive $15 million. But, he said, that money should not be dedicated to the Port Authority.
"I'm not so sure about moving the Port Authority out of the property tax revenue stream," he said. He explained that property taxes are a reliable source of revenue that is more secure than taxes that can fluctuate.
During the first committee meeting about next year's budget, Mr. Gastgeb raised questions about why the rental car tax was included under special accounts. He wondered if, by putting it there, the tax could be adopted with a simple majority instead of a two-thirds vote of the 15-member council.
During his two terms on council, Mr. Gastgeb said, the county parks have gotten better and council has pushed for greater accountability from the Board of Health.
He recently proposed opening a free parking lot at Pittsburgh International Airport where people could wait for arriving passengers without having to go inside the terminal.
Currently people park on the shoulder of Route 60 in Findlay to wait for passengers to call -- creating a potentially dangerous situation along the busy four-lane highway.
Mrs. Logan would like to see council go back to the state to lobby for a different source of revenue for mass transit. She suggested a gasoline tax. She also said Port Authority of Allegheny County should develop a system to better track what bus routes are being used and when so that buses can be directed to the areas where the need is greatest.
Mrs. Logan also would like to use her seat on council to work toward a regional planning system for new developments to avoid another situation such as what happened in Kilbuck when the developer, who was trying to build a Wal-Mart, instead sent a huge pile of dirt sliding onto Route 65.
Mrs. Logan applauded County Council for pushing the smoking issue by banning smoking in restaurants, a measure that was ultimately struck down by the courts. She said it raised the issue statewide. She would like to see the same sort of activism taken on school lunches.
Mr. Gastgeb is one of the original members of County Council, which was formed in 2000. He's a 1981 graduate of Bethel Park High School and a 1985 graduate of the University of Pittsburgh, where he majored in political science.
Mr. Gastgeb has been a sales manager for Sara Lee for the past 10 years and been in the consumer food business for 20 years.
Mrs. Logan was born in Port Huron, Mich., and holds a master's degree in English from the University of Toledo. She taught high school English in Cincinnati and also has taught at the University of Toledo.
She moved to Mt. Lebanon in 1977 and was elected to the Mt. Lebanon Board of Commissioners in 1995. Mrs. Logan serves on the board of trustees for Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh and the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh.
As a member of the League of Women Voters, she was on the committee that helped eliminate the system of three commissioners running the county and instead creating a strong executive with a 15-member council.
The fifth district also is made up of Bethel Park, Mt. Lebanon and Upper St. Clair.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.