A check of three key districts in which absentee-ballot irregularities had been suspected didn't produce any vote-altering mistakes in the Moon Area school board primary, prompting the Republican Committee of Moon Township to drop its request for a recount Monday.
As a result, the May results stand and a change in board leadership come November seems likely, acknowledged Shirlee Nelson, committee chairwoman.
Four votes had separated the party-backed incumbent Barbara Nolfi, who finished sixth, from Nick Pollack, who finished fifth. Five seats are being contested and because of cross-party filing, Mr. Pollack is a virtual shoo-in to win in November, Ms. Nelson said.
The same five candidates now will appear on the Democratic and GOP ballots.
Mr. Pollack is expected to join incumbents Mark Scappe and Lisa Wolowicz on the new board, along with newcomers Rose Varsanik and Mark Ulven. The five ran as a team.
"I guess I really wasn't worried about it. If it was meant to be it was meant to be," he said, adding that the historical odds of a recount changing the outcome were not high. Still, he was glad that the issue has been resolved.
Ms. Nelson said the party had decided to pursue a recount because of reports that several absentee ballots might have been lost or miscounted. She said the number of ballots that had been mailed out seemed substantially higher than the number tallied.
Had Ms. Nolfi won in a recount, the current board majority might have been able to sustain its hold in November, Ms. Nelson explained.
She said a total of 77 absentee ballots from Districts 2, 5 and 9 were chosen for a ballot-by-ballot review Monday as directed by Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James.
Judge James did not attend the one-hour audit held Monday morning at the county election bureau Downtown, Ms. Nelson said. When the party dropped the recount request, she said a formal hearing became unnecessary.
"There were no mistakes found. We're not going to contest the results," Ms. Nelson said Monday evening.
Actually, she said there was one mistake found, but it did not change the outcome. A District 9 ballot was accidentally placed in a District 2 envelope, she said.
A full recount would have involved a total of 15 voting districts -- two in Crescent and 13 in Moon. The District 2 polling station was at the township municipal building, District 5 was at Bon Meade Elementary School and District 9 was at the Moon Area Middle School.
Even though she was disappointed that Ms. Nolfi had indeed lost, Ms. Nelson had only praise for the recount audit itself.
"I was pleased with the way it was handled. It was certainly enlightening," she said. The computer scanners used for the first time this May to check the absentee ballots seemed far more reliable than hand-counted tallies, she added.
A 40-year veteran of Moon politics, Ms. Nelson said this was the first time she could recall that a Moon school board race came this close to a recount.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.