Beaver County Controller Richard W. Towcimak said he ran this year's campaign in the same fashion as his winning bids during a 24-year career.

This time, though, the outcome was an upset in Tuesday's primary. Unofficial results show Mr. Towcimak lost the Democratic nomination by nearly 2,000 votes to Monaca Councilman David A. Rossi, 34, a trust accountant for Mellon Financial.

Both Mr. Towcimak and his opponent said they sensed voters wanted change. And a negative campaigning tactic by the Democrats -- unveiling early in the campaign Mr. Rossi's three drunken-driving arrests from years ago -- did not seem to have any impact.

"Two simple words: people over politics," said Mr. Rossi, who described himself as a changed man since his arrests. He did not shrink from discussing his troubles. "You put the residents of Beaver County first over politics and you're going to move forward. We've got to come together and stop being negative and aggressive to each other."

Advertise with us

Mr. Towcimak's loss shocked members of both parties, and fellow row officers seemed dumbfounded at the turn of events.

"It is a surprise. Things were very quiet, and we never got that much feedback that there was that much public nonsupport," said Vincent LaValle, chairman of the Democratic Party Committee. "It's a big loss because he has been a party stalwart and he has been with the party for a long time, and I think that may have been part of the problem, too."

Mr. Towcimak, 56, of Economy, remained a power broker long after his term as committee chairman from 1990 to 1996. Most recently he has been chairman of the prison board and backed winning sheriff's candidate George J. David, the county jail's security chief.

Eugene "Salt" Smith, Aliquippa's Democratic chairman, traced Mr. Towcimak's loss directly to friction over the sheriff's race. Mr. Towcimak and the county Democratic committee supported Mr. David, while Aliquippa backed hometown favorite William F. Alston Jr. That led to bad blood

"We beat the man who caused all the confusion, Rick Towcimak. He was the one who said he didn't need Aliquippa's votes, and he didn't get them," Mr. Smith said.

Advertise with us

Both Mr. Smith and Donald J. Paisley, a Democratic challenger for commissioner from Big Beaver, called Mr. Towcimak "arrogant" and reflected a strong undercurrent against the controller in the party.

"This is based on an attitude of arrogance that the public perceived, and he paid the price for it," Mr. Paisley said.

Although glum Tuesday night when reached in his office, Mr. Towcimak wished his opponent well. He said he would aid in the transition if Mr. Rossi wins the November general election, as is expected.

Mr. Towcimak said he was unsure if releasing the information about Mr. Rossi's arrest record backfired,

"It came out early and then it was never mentioned again," Mr. Towcimak said. "We thought that it was pertinent to his judgment and that's water over the dam."

Advertise with us

Some observers believe Mr. Towcimak's loss is likely to produce a temporary power vacuum among the county's Democratic Party.

"Now who is the leader in the courthouse?" asked Marty Matthews, chairman of the Republican Committee of Beaver County. "I thought he was stronger than that. But when you watched his campaign and some of the things he did, you got the impression he felt he was vulnerable."

Commissioners

Beaver restaurateur Gregory H. Powell will join incumbent Commissioner Charles A. Camp on the Republican ticket in November, while Center Supervisor Anthony Amadio joins Commissioner Joseph G. Spanik on the Democratic slate.

The four will vie for three seats, and Mr. Powell predicted that Mr. Spanik would be the weakest candidate, in light of his coming in second place behind Mr. Amadio.

Advertise with us

"We can do Republican dominance there," Mr. Powell, 44, said Tuesday, still somewhat surprised by his finish.

Mr. Spanik selected Mr. Powell as most likely to lose in November because of his neophyte status.

Mr. Camp, 50, of Patterson, called Mr. Powell a "great man," but it remains to be seen whether they can coordinate a campaign as their Democratic opponents are doing.

Mr. Matthews, the GOP chairman, recalled problems in the 2003 election when Mr. Camp and the other Republican on the ballot, James A. Roberts, could not work well enough together to take a majority among the commissioners.

"Charlie and Jim, although they were acquaintances and friends, they just couldn't seem to agree on how to do a joint campaign," Mr. Matthews said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Camp knows that he will have to campaign hard between now and the general election. He pointed to Mr. Towcimak's loss.

"It shows that you've got to earn the voters respect. You can't take them for granted," Mr. Camp said.

Candidates' campaigns will likely focus on job creation and economic growth. But one looming issue that could prove thorny for both incumbents is their controversial support last year of a failed attempt to privatize the jail, which soured some union backing.

Mr. Spanik, a former labor official, said that support likely hurt his attractiveness in the primary, leading him to finish behind Mr. Amadio, a political veteran but a newcomer to countywide campaigning.

Mr. Spanik, 60, also pointed to difficulties posed by the break in ranks by Aliquippa Democrats.

Advertise with us

"These were major hurdles," Mr. Spanik said.

Sheriff

Some say Mr. David has been running for sheriff since 1997. That year, after serving in the position for a year as an appointee, he lost the election to outgoing Sheriff Felix DeLuca Jr.

On Tuesday, Mr. David won a squeaker, edging out Mr. Alston, the former Aliquippa police chief, and Beaver Falls Police Capt. Jay P. Alstadt, to win the Democratic nod.

Mr. Smith, the Aliquippa Democratic committee chairman, said he believes Mr. Alstadt drained some votes from Mr. Alston, possibly because of confusion over the similar-sounding surnames.

Advertise with us

Mr. David, 59, of Aliquippa will face the Republican winner, retired Brighton police chief Jack E. Erath, 72, in what some believe might be a close race.

"We're gonna try our best," Mr. Erath said.

Common Pleas Judge

Although Assistant District Attorney Kim Tesla received the lowest ranking by the Beaver County Bar Association of the six cross-filed candidates for Common Pleas judge, he was the top vote-getter among Democrats and came in second on the Republican ballot.

In the end, he said, voters mattered more than the association.

Advertise with us

"Maybe they just didn't appreciate the work I did," Mr. Tesla said. "My record was one that [voters] believe in."

Mr. Tesla, 51, of Hopewell, in his third bid for a judgeship, will face Ambridge District Judge Harry E. Knafelc, 59, and John L. Walker Jr., 54, of Brighton, the only registered Republican, for two seats on the court. Judge Knafelc's campaign is also his third.

"I think it's going to be very challenging," Judge Knafelc. "The most important thing for me is to meet and talk to as many people as I possibly can."

Mr. Walker will be competing with two candidates who have extensive campaign experience and good name recognition.

"I'm encouraged," Mr. Walker said. "Back in January, my goal was to come out of the primary and be one of the candidates on the ballot in November. I accomplished that goal."