Two candidates for Beaver County Common Pleas Court hope the third time is the charm in a field crowded with political neophytes.
Ambridge District Judge Harry E. Knafelc and Assistant District Attorney Kim Tesla, of Hopewell, both of whom enjoy name recognition in the county by merit of their positions, hope publicity from their past campaigns for the bench will give them an edge in the May 15 primary.
They are among six candidates competing to fill two judgeships that will open because of retirements. Judges Robert E. Kunselman and George E. James hit mandatory retirement age this year and will step down in December.
John L. Walker Jr., of Brighton, is the only registered Republican, but all candidates are cross-filed.
The other candidates for the 10-year posts, which pay $152,115 a year, are Diane Zack Buchanan, of Hanover; Mitchell P. Shahen, of Center; and George A. Verlihay, of Chippewa.
Mr. Tesla and Judge Knafelc have earned the Democratic nod, while the GOP is backing Mr. Walker.
The race would be wrapped up this month if the same two people are the top vote-getters on both the Democratic and Republican ballots. If not, three or four candidates will be on the ballot in November's general election.
More than half the voting members of the Beaver County Bar Association recommended all the candidates except Ms. Buchanan and Mr. Tesla last month.
Ms. Buchanan, 52, came to the law late in life. She had a first career for nearly 20 years as a registered nurse and administrator at Mercy Hospital and a second one as a mother of three. Her exposure to legal issues led her to law school in the evenings and now to the race for judge.
"It's coming at a point in my life my youngest is a senior. She's going off to school. I'll have an empty nest, and I'll have the time to once again serve the community in Beaver County," Ms. Buchanan said. "I think my background is diverse enough I can relate to the issues."
Half of Ms. Buchanan's private practice is devoted to family law. She was, briefly, an assistant county solicitor and continues to represent several public entities, including Beaver County Airport and Rochester Township's zoning board.
Ms. Buchanan described herself as organized, hard-working and caring but not a pushover. She has never prosecuted a jury trial and said she did not feel her limited experience in criminal law was a liability.
"I don't think it would be hard. I'm not intimidated doing criminal law," Ms. Buchanan said. "I probably have the broadest background for civil litigation."
Judge Knafelc, 59, who ran for Common Pleas Court in 1997 and 2001, described himself as a "known commodity" and the only candidate with true judicial experience.
"I do not believe in judicial activism. I believe that judges at the Common Pleas Court level must use good common sense in interpreting the law, giving an interpretation of that law based on the intent of the people in the state Legislature," Judge Knafelc said.
Judge Knafelc was a Common Pleas Court law clerk before joining the public defender's office in 1973 for a 20-year career that saw him ascend to chief trial counsel. He became a district judge in 1994.
Mr. Shahen, 49, is one of four criminal-conflicts lawyers in Beaver County who represent indigent people when the public defender's office cannot because of conflict of interest.
In addition to his private practice, which handles civil and criminal cases, Mr. Shahen is solicitor for Georgetown and Hookstown.
He has been appointed to handle post-conviction relief act cases, which review effectiveness of trial counsel or constitutionality of convictions.
Mr. Shahen said he wanted to be a judge because, "I think it's a place where somebody with qualifying experience and the right temperament can make a difference by being fair."
Kim Tesla, 51, a veteran prosecutor, said being a judge was "that ultimate conclusion of your public service." He ran in 2003 and 2005.
Mr. Tesla touted his decision to work as a public servant throughout his career instead of going into private practice.
"I prefer to use my skills in the public sector. Without tooting my own horn, I would say I'm attracted to fighting causes," Mr. Tesla said.
A onetime construction worker, Mr. Tesla put himself through law school at night. After clerking for judges in Washington County Common Pleas Court and state Superior Court, Mr. Tesla went to work for Neighborhood Legal Services, the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee and the Women's Center of Beaver County. He became a prosecutor in 1990.
Mr. Tesla said he had prosecuted more than 100 jury trials, doing extensive work early on with drunken driving cases and fatal collisions and then progressing to violent crimes. He was deputized as a special deputy attorney general during the investigation into the 2001 slaying of Aliquippa police Officer James Naim.
Mr. Verlihay, 58, a civil trial lawyer from Chippewa with numerous municipal clients, went to work out of law school for a firm run by retired Beaver County Common Pleas Judge Thomas E. Mannix. When Judge Mannix took the bench in 1978, Mr. Verlihay adopted his clients. For the past 10 years, Mr. Verlihay has worked alone.
Mr. Verlihay said he had links to another jurist. Judge John D. McBride was a fraternity brother, and Mr. Verlihay ran his two campaigns.
"I have always seen that office as the culmination of a legal career. and I think I have the knowledge, scholarship, expertise and temperance to be a good jurist," Mr. Verlihay said.
Asked what sets him apart, Mr. Verlihay said, "My civil trial experience and my breadth of legal experience." He said his limited criminal court experience was not an impediment.
John L. Walker Jr., 54, an appointed master in Juvenile Court since 1998, estimated he had presided at more than 8,000 proceedings. He said he handled a wide range of civil and criminal cases in private practice.
"I had an interest in youth and so I have grown to enjoy that work and, really, as a result of that work as Juvenile Court master, that's probably the main reason, along with my many years of practice, that I'm seeking election as judge this year," Mr. Walker said.
This is his first campaign.
"I've always thought that attorneys who run for the bench ought to be well-seasoned and experienced. Maybe four, five years ago, I would not have thought about doing this. At this point ... I think I've got that experience [to] serve the bench, the public and the bar as judge," Mr. Walker said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.