The existing Sto-Rox school board is already split into distinct factions, with Kevin Kochirka, John Karpa, Lenora Karpa, Luanne Schipani, Linda Jacobs and Carlton Brown in the majority and Ed Maritz, Betty Bencho and Donna Parrilla forming a fairly consistent minority.

In a broad-brush sense, the majority has kept the district to a severe fiscal diet, and points with pride to a more stable bottom line. The minority, meanwhile, keeps raising concerns that academics have been gutted in the process.

With such a worthy debate going on, the upcoming board elections were bound to be contentious anyway. Then, in January, Judge Joseph James, president judge of Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, threw a whole new twist on things by ordering a move from at-large elections, which have been dominated by Stowe candidates in recent years, to regional ones, with seats dedicated to McKees Rocks residents and Stowe residents.

The end result is that two incumbents -- Mr. Kochirka and Ms. Bencho -- are battling for one available at-large seat, and both factions have candidates for all the regional seats -- two each in Stowe and McKees Rocks.

Advertise with us

The breakdown is this: Mr. Kochirka is campaigning with newcomers Barb Kitt and Jean Mayes in Stowe and newcomer Holly Woodson and incumbent Mr. Brown in McKees Rocks. The opposition is less unified, but has Elizabeth Smith and Jeanne Hughes running in McKees Rocks and Cheri Zielinski and incumbent Ms. Parrilla running in Stowe.

John Karpa has chosen not to run; Lenora Karpa, Ms. Schipani, Ms. Jacobs and Mr. Maritz are not due for election until 2009. The board is sure to have at least two new faces next year.

Mr. Kochirka said the district has gone from a $1.8 million shortfall to a $1.6 million fund balance during his tenure, through moves like consolidating elementary classrooms and administrative offices and stepping up the collection of delinquent taxes.

He granted that there have been academic cuts, but "now that we have the money in the budget, we can start looking at improving education."

Mr. Brown also said he sees a team coming together in the district.

Advertise with us

"Our schools had had a lot of changes," he said. "We couldn't keep principals, couldn't get that sense of everyone gelling.

"But in the last year I saw the teachers and administration go from 'we-they' to 'we can do this together.' "

Both men said they saw the move to regional elections -- which was spearheaded by Ms. Smith and her fiance, Mr. Maritz -- as regressive.

"I think it's going backward," Mr. Brown said. "Wherever you go around here, when you ask people where they're from, they say 'The Rocks.' I think we need to concentrate on school problems, not Rocks problems or Stowe problems."

"It's back to the Stone Age," Ms. Mayes echoed, noting that there were two separate high schools until the 1960s and that there were conflicts following the merger.

Advertise with us

"It took the community forever to get united on that," she said. "It's just politics, somebody's agenda to pat themselves on the back."

Ms. Smith had a quite different view.

"I'm glad to see people now have an opportunity to be involved," she said. "There are three other people [from McKees Rocks] out there now seeking an opportunity to serve. ... Even if I lose, this has been good for the McKees Rocks community. They are involved."

Ms. Smith said she was drawn to run after working with a strategic planning committee trying to chart a course for the district's future. She said she found it discouraging that board members were not involved.

And she and Ms. Zielinski decried the school's practice of offering tutoring to children "on the bubble" as far as standardized tests go; if those children score well, the district can meet goals set by the state and federal governments and get more grant money.

Advertise with us

The candidates said, though, that tutoring should be offered to all students, and claimed the district was simply writing off some children on the basis that even with tutoring they wouldn't score well enough on the tests.

Ms. Zielinski said that's an example of how the district has gotten away from educational basics, and it needs to focus on getting all kids the essential skills they need for life.

"I'd like to see academic pride take precedence over athletic pride," she said. "I want to be an advocate for all the children."

She also touted herself as an independent candidate, a longtime "pain in the butt" as a citizen attending school board meetings, with as many arguments with Mr. Maritz as with anyone in the majority.

Ms. Bencho echoed that stance. "I have my own mind," she said. "I vote the way I believe is right."

Advertise with us

Describing herself as "the senior citizen on this board," she looks back to her beginnings as a school director for her sense of what is right. She came on the board in 1993 when the district was still run by a state-appointed board of control.

"I learned a lot from watching them work, how they discussed things among the three of them," she said.

She feels that she now has little chance to influence things herself.

"We can't seem to work together, and it's not good to be on the outside looking in," she said.

Ms. Bencho said she favors the change to regional voting -- "McKees Rocks needs to have a say-so" -- even though it could cost her her seat. She and Mr. Kochirka both live in Stowe.

Advertise with us

"When it gets to 3-3-3," she said -- three McKees Rocks representatives, three Stowe representatives and three at-large, which will be in 2010 -- "it will be a really good board," she said.

Ms. Kitt, Ms. Parrilla, Ms. Hughes and Ms. Woodson could not be reached for comment.