A new hotel and an old police force would have a hard time making it into the same conversation except on Neville Island, where they are issues in a high profile commissioners' race.

With only one incumbent running, there is a wide open field of six candidates vying for three seats on the five-member board on the ballot in the May 15 primary. Township commissioners Richard Phillips and Jim McGrath chose not to run, both citing health issues. All the candidates are Democrats.

At large

Gregory Mundell has heard a few complaints in his day as a US Airways supervisor of customer services. He's also heard a few as a resident of Neville, coming from neighbors upset about last winter's disbanding of the township police force.

Advertise with us

"The question is not whether it was right or wrong," he said, "but the way they went about it. There wasn't enough input. They listened to it and their minds were all made up."

Like many critics of the decision to outsource the work to neighboring Ohio Township, Mr. Mundell has only praise for the new law enforcers. "But I think the in-house people would do a better job."

Now, he's concerned that the next shoe is set to fall -- the outsourcing of the three public works jobs, snow and leaf removal.

Overall, though, he sees blue skies ahead thanks to things like the new, four-story, 110-room Fairfield Inn Marriott. The hotel is owned by Neville Metals President Charles Snyder and will be situated at the site of the former Community College of Allegheny County technology center on Grand Avenue.

"We're finally getting some new business in Neville Island," he said, praising Mr. Snyder's commitment. "With him we're seeing new progress with business. That's my main concern."

Advertise with us

Mr. Mundell, 53, is a 1972 graduate of Cornell High School in Coraopolis, which was the first graduating class.

Howard McEachern is at that age where he finds new demands on his time. At 62, he can see the end of a successful career in finance, now as a UPMC technology project leader.

He also sees a new life as a public servant. Or not.

"The nice thing for me is if I win, I get in," he said. "If not, I can go fishing."

His consideration of all options should not be construed as a lack of interest in being a leader in Neville's future. It's as bright as he's seen it, which is why he's hit the campaign trail.

Advertise with us

He is one of three Democratic Party-endorsed candidates, along with incumbent Aaron Kohan and William Easton.

Mr. McEachern is a business information systems graduate from Robert Morris. He has worked for 40-plus years in financial services at J.P. Morgan, PNC Bank and UPMC.

"The township is in a very good position to go forward. ... I feel I'd be truly an asset," he said.

Things began to brighten, he said, when the Island Sports Center was opened in 1999, then expanded when Robert Morris took it over in 2003. The new Marriott adds to the lustre.

"That was the catalyst for all the change over the next four years. After that happened," he said, "what they need are business people on the board and I am a business person."

Advertise with us

Ward 1

Aaron Kohan is the lone incumbent in the race and wants to put last year's big issue behind him.

Poor health, not criticism over disbanding police department, prompted his colleagues to head to the sidelines. Still, by all accounts, the outsourcing decision has taken a toll, he said, even though the Ohio Township police who've been patrolling for more than a year are doing a fine job.

"There's been some controversy since we eliminated the police department, although it's worked out to the good and we saved a lot of money," Mr. Kohan said.

"Some people still don't like it, even though we lowered our taxes 36 percent," he said. People also are slow to appreciate improvements the savings have paid for, such as a new firetruck and extra road repairs, he said.

Advertise with us

The police contract, which yielded a savings of about $500,000 a year, allowed taxes to be cut 2.5 mills.

"I don't know if there's a super big issue right now. We're moving in the right direction, we just want to continue looking at ways to make it more attractive for development," said Mr. Kohan, who is serving his second nonconsecutive term.

Born and raised in Neville, Mr. Kohan, 50, is a steamfitter and member of Pittsburgh Steamfitters Local 449. He is a graduate of Cornell High School and attended Edinboro University of Pennsylvania.

Allen Whitaker is stepping up because he doesn't like the way the present board handled the police issue. A highway worker for the state Department of Transportation, he does his job out in the open, which he said is something current officials should be doing.

"I'm a rookie now," but that's about to change. "Neville Island needs a change from the direction they're heading. I'm all about change."

Advertise with us

What particularly upsets him about the board is "the way they've been doing things behind people's backs. They write ordinances but don't back them up, and residents are getting shafted."

Hiring out-of-towners for police protection in early 2006 was one thing, he said. But he can't believe that based on a brief record of performance, the board in March decided to extend the pact with Ohio Township police through 2013.

"They're not listening to what people tell them. ... I think the money they're spending could be better spent."

Mr. Whitaker, 47, has been a PennDOT maintenance worker for 20 years. He is a graduate of Moon Area High School.

Ward 3

Advertise with us

William Easton came back. He believes the township as a whole can do the same.

Mr. Easton's first and second attempts at becoming a township commissioner are separated by 26 years. He ran for office in 1981 but said he had to withdraw because he moved from Neville. He moved back to town five years ago after living in Coraopolis and Moon. Why?

"I always wanted a house on the island by the river and one came available," he said, of his home on Pine Road.

Since coming back, Mr. Easton has been active on the Neville Island Development Association. Signs of the island turning the corner, he said, can be seen at the foot of the I-79 interstate ramps. That's where the new Fairfield Inn is going, as well as a nearby Subway sandwich shop. Next up is a sit-down, family-style restaurant on an adjoining riverfront tract.

"We've been working real hard and things are looking real good for us now," he said.

Advertise with us

"Growing up here I remember what it was like. I was here for the start of the decline," he said. What he hopes to see, he added, "is if some recession comes about, the island will be better prepared than the last time around."

Mr. Easton, 51, is manager of Edgeworth Water Authority and graduated from Cornell High School.

David Mazzocco was as disappointed as anybody when he showed up at Cornell High School at 8 a.m. April 3 and Gov. Ed Rendell didn't.

The governor was a late scratch from the Classrooms for the Future ribbon-cutting. The governor came to Cornell a week later, but Mr. Mazzocco decided not to take a chance.

"What's the saying? Fool me once. . . . I wasn't going to give him the opportunity."

Advertise with us

A member of the Cornell school board, Mr. Mazzocco adopts the same philosophy in expressing skepticism about the economic development in Neville. He said tax abatement programs can spell trouble for high-profile, showcase pieces such as the Island Sports Center.

"You'll see no tax revenue for five years," he said of the Robert Morris University-owned ice center. "It's not as good a deal as the incumbents are saying. That was going to be our cash cow for our lifetime, and it turned out to be donated to a tax-exempt organization."

Neville Commissioner Bill Leon said while he understands Mr. Mazzocco's concern, he's got the facts wrong. The RMU center is not tax-exempt, as many believe. The university is paying property taxes to the township, he said, albeit indirectly.

Since buying the center from a subsidiary of the Hillman Corp. in 2003 for some $10 million, the university has been paying in annual installments a $42,000 debt to the Hillman subsidiary -- money that otherwise the township would have to pay because of the Hillmans' successful property assessment appeal, Mr. Leon said.

Mr. Mazzocco, 48, is an auditor at Mellon Financial Corp. He grew up on the island and moved back about 13 years ago. He has an accounting degree from Slippery Rock University.