Tim McConnell's days as an ex-coach didn't last long.

Mr. McConnell, the highly successful boys' basketball coach at Chartiers Valley High School, will be getting his job back after being fired Tuesday night by the school board.

Yesterday afternoon, four of the five board members who voted against Mr. McConnell decided to rescind their vote and rehire him.

In a statement, board members said a public outcry against Mr. McConnell's ouster was the reason for their change of heart. Mr. McConnell, 42, had a 317-88 record in 14 seasons as coach, with four WPIAL championships.

Advertise with us

Mr. McConnell said he will accept his job again, but the move can't be official until the board holds a formal vote. That could come at the next scheduled board meeting April 24, although board member Jeff Hilty said the nine-member board might hold a special meeting earlier to rehire Mr. McConnell.

"I'm excited in one aspect, but I'm not going to say it's over until it's official and they vote at the board meeting," Mr. McConnell said. "I've seen stranger things happen."

Chartiers Valley Athletic Director Frank Vulcano informed Mr. McConnell at 3:30 yesterday that the board would be issuing a statement saying he will be rehired.

"I don't feel revenge. I just feel justice has been served," said Mr. McConnell, before leaving to coach a youth team in an AAU tournament last night in Solon, Ohio.

Mr. McConnell also is dean of students at Chartiers Valley Middle School.

Advertise with us

The statement issued by the four board members -- Mr. Hilty, Beth McIntyre, Patti Frey and Mary Lou Petronsky -- read, "We really believe we were acting in the best interests of the students. But after the community made its feelings known, we've come to conclusion that as public servants, we need to consider our obligation to speak as a voice of our public."

They, along with board member Tony Moses, voted to seek new applicants for Mr. Connell's position. Mr. Moses did not want to be part of the release and said he will still vote against Mr. McConnell.

Mr. McConnell and others close to the Chartiers Valley basketball program have said Mr. Moses was the leader of a two-year crusade to have Mr. McConnell fired because Mr. Moses' son, Mike, rarely plays on Chartiers Valley's team. Mr. McConnell accused Mr. Moses of swaying other board members to his side.

Mr. Moses said he didn't want to be listed on the news release "for the same reason that I voted against [Mr. McConnell]. I'm not a hypocrite. If I have to face the music by myself, I'll face it by myself. There are elections coming up and that had everything to do with this. Some threats were made to people by anonymous phone calls.

"I've taken a stance and I'm not going to succumb to public pressure. I felt right and I'm not going to change my mind."

Advertise with us

Mr. McConnell said, "With him not signing [the news release], it just tells me what everybody thought all along -- that he had a personal vendetta against me, and that he led the crusade."

Seven of the nine board members, excluding Mr. Hilty and Mr. Moses, were in San Francisco yesterday for a national school board convention. Mr. Hilty said he decided to rescind his vote and discussed the issue on the telephone with the others who had voted against Mr. McConnell.

Not all board members were in on the discussion. Jeff Choura, who voted for Mr. McConnell, didn't know about the votes being rescinded until a reporter informed him last night.

"Every elected official has the right to change his vote," said Mr. Choura, a board member for 30 years. "But the vote should've never taken place in the first place. He's a wonderful coach, a wonderful dean of students and a pillar in this community. There was no merit for his firing in the first place."

Mr. Hilty said, "I can tell you why I rescinded my vote. I looked at the whole picture and all this bad publicity Chartiers Valley was getting. I've spent my entire life in Chartiers Valley. My names are on trophies at the school. I played sports there. It was important to me to move on. We were elected by the public and the public thinks this is the best idea [to rehire Mr. McConnell]. So I changed my vote."

Advertise with us

Mr. Hilty had said one of the reasons the board opened Mr. McConnell's position was because he looked into other jobs. Mr. McConnell openly admitted he recently interviewed for the vacant athletic director's job at Baldwin and sent a resume to the Ringgold School District for its open athletic director's job.

"But I never, ever looked for a basketball job," Mr. McConnell said.

Mr. Moses' son is a junior at Chartiers Valley and when asked if he would be welcomed back to the team next season, Mr. McConnell said, "All I can say is I may have differences with a parent, but I can't hold that against a kid. If he decides to come back out for the team, I can promise that he will be treated fairly and be given every opportunity to be part of the team, just like every other kid. I will do the same as I've done in the past and that's play the best kids, the ones who deserve to play. If I'm asked to do anything different by anybody, then I will not be the coach at Chartiers Valley."

Mr. McConnell added, "I know there were some things said on both sides. I just hope I will be treated fairly and be able to move on, and do my job."