The rest of the world knew Big Beaver Councilman Jim Marshall had beaten State Rep. Mike Veon long before Mr. Marshall did himself.

Mr. Marshall, a Republican, had a somewhat impromptu party at his house Tuesday night, and had word filtering in that he had won. But with no results posted until after midnight and no concession call from Mr. Veon, he was unsure.

It became very clear the next morning, when he got up, took out the garbage, got a cup of coffee and headed out to cut the grass, only to find television news crews at the door.

Andy Starnes, Post-Gazette

Advertise with us

Incumbent state Rep. Mike Veon talks to Dick Klugh, a volunteer, after voting Tuesday in the West Mayfield Volunteer Fire Dept. in Beaver County.

Click photo for larger image.

It was the only election-night upset in the West where two legislative incumbents were elected without opposition, three incumbents defeated challengers and three newcomers won in districts where incumbents were either defeated in May or will be retiring.

Mr. Marshall said his reaction to the surprising win was not to seek any congratulations for himself.

"I say congratulations to the voters of this district. They did what they set out to do; they unseated Mike Veon," he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Veon, a Democrat from West Mayfield, is House Minority Whip, a 22-year legislator and one of Harrisburg's most powerful men. But he shot himself in the foot when he engineered a legislative pay raise in July 2005 and then cast the sole dissenting vote when it was repealed.

"I felt he was in there too long," Mr. Marshall said. "His outlook changed, and I think he's in denial that his outlook changed,"

Mr. Marshall said a key moment for him came when he heard Mr. Veon compare himself to the CEO of a large corporation.

"He's not the CEO; he's the employee," Mr. Marshall said. "He's the representative of the people of the 14th, and that's it."

And as a career politician, "he says he represents the common man on the street, but he's never been one," Mr. Marshall said.

Advertise with us

For himself, he plans to head to Harrisburg as a common man first, a family man and firefighter twice laid off from closing steel mills.

He ran on a ticket of honesty, integrity and true representation of the people. His primary issue is making local government simpler through cooperation or even mergers among school districts and municipalities.

And he freely grants that he was "lucky."

"This election was not about me. It was about unseating Mike Veon," he said.

It happened, and Mr. Marshall's grass is still unmowed.

Advertise with us

"I got a call from someone asking me what I want on my temporary stationery," he said -- clear that it was not a question he'd prepared for. "I got another call; they want me to go to Harrisburg [today] to talk about starting to hire staff."

It seems surreal to him; he considers himself very much an average guy.

"My goal is to represent the people of my district," he said. "I'm one of them."

Elsewhere, legislators State Rep. Sean Ramaley, D-Economy, 16th District; and Nick Kotik, R-Robinson, 45th District; were unopposed. Here's a roundup of the contested races in West and Beaver County legislative districts based on unofficial results:

10th District

Advertise with us

Jaret Gibbons, 26, of Ellwood City, a political newcomer, defeated Republican Chuck Morse, of Slippery Rock. Mr. Gibbons had ousted 20-year Democratic incumbent Frank LaGrotta in the May primary. He has worked as an aide to state Sen. Jay Costa, a project manager for Moon's finance department and has taught mentally challenged children.

The 10th District covers Franklin, Marion, New Sewickley, North Sewickley and Economy in Beaver County and 12 towns in Lawrence County and two communities in Butler County.

15th District

With incumbents crashing and burning all around him, State Rep. Vince Biancucci, of Center, was delighted with an apparent victory, no matter how close.

"Fifty-one percent of the people voted for me, and that's all you need," he said yesterday morning, after going to bed on election night with uncertainty still hanging over the race.

Advertise with us

The two-term legislator from Center defeated Republican challenger Todd Hockenberry, of Beaver.

Mr. Hockenberry was not ready to concede Wednesday, saying he had some questions about absentee ballots. An optical scanner broke down at the courthouse Tuesday night, delaying the counting of absentee ballots until about 4 a.m. yesterday.

"Clearly, Democrats turned out," he said. And he noted that based on vote totals, there were plenty of voters who cast ballots for Democrats in other races, but also voted for him.

Mr. Biancucci, meanwhile, pronounced the race "too close for me," attributing the slim margin to a general vote for change across the state and nation.

He also thinks he was hurt by Republican efforts to link him with Mike Veon, the House Minority Whip from Beaver Falls who was defeated.

Advertise with us

"Mike constantly was being dragged into my race," he said. And while they were close colleagues, Mr. Biancucci noted -- for the umpteenth time -- that he did not vote for the July 2005 legislative pay raise, and did not accept the money.

And while Mr. Biancucci will be more comfortable when the vote totals are certified, he said he's looking forward to getting back to Harrisburg and getting back to work on programs for the betterment of his district.

"I want to go on making good things happen in Beaver County," he said.

27th District

State Rep. Thomas Petrone, D-Crafton Heights, who has held his seat for 26 years easily defeated his Republican challenger Crafton Councilman William Ogden.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ogden, 45, had made a campaign issue of the fact that Mr. Petrone, 69, voted for and accepted the controversial pay raise that was later rescinded. And though that was enough to run some other incumbents out of office in both the primary and Tuesday's general election, it didn't appear to affect Mr. Petrone.

"My people know me. They know what I do for the district," said Mr. Petrone, who has said he is making installment payments back to the state for the amount of the pay raise that he accepted.

Mr. Petrone attributed part of his success to what he called his "hardworking staff" which operates the many outreach programs he offers for senior citizens such as those that assist with tax preparation, PACE applications and medicare plan selections.

The 27th District includes neighborhoods in Pittsburgh's West End. It also includes Avalon, Ben Avon, Crafton, Dormont, Emsworth, Glenfield, Ingram, Neville and parts of McKees Rocks.

Mr. Ogden said the most difficult battle he had in the race was to try to crack the heavy Democratic support that Mr. Petrone had in city neighborhoods. In addition, Mr. Ogden said, the anti-Republican sentiment that seemed to trickle down from national and state-wide elections didn't help his race either.

Advertise with us

42nd District

After five-time Republican incumbent Tom Stevenson lost to Mark Harris in the May primary, voters knew they'd have change after this week's election, but it wasn't clear just who -- or which party -- would take over that seat.

Democrat Matthew Smith, 34, of Mt. Lebanon, a lawyer with Babst Calland Clements & Zomnir in Pittsburgh, won handily.

"We absolutely brought home a victory," Mr. Smith said at his election night headquarters at Molly Brannigans in Mt. Lebanon. "This was a victory from Bethel Park all the way up to Rosslyn Farms." As he spoke, he held his arms high in the air like a winning prizefighter.

Mr. Smith believed it was his door-to-door effort that made the difference with voters. More than 50 regular volunteers also helped behind the scenes and just getting people to the polls was a major goal.

Advertise with us

Mr. Harris, 21, of Mt. Lebanon, said he got caught up in a wave of change that locked out many Republicans due to voters' displeasure with performance of those currently in power.

The district includes Mt. Lebanon, Green Tree, Rosslyn Farms, Thornburg and portions of Scott and Bethel Park.

44th District

Less than 12 hours after being re-elected to his second full term, state Rep. Mark Mustio, R-Moon, already had removed his campaign lawn signs and was driving to Harrisburg to resume his work on reducing the size of the Legislature.

"I am looking forward to working with my new colleagues to find out if they will make a commitment to join me in downsizing the size of the Legislature," said Mr. Mustio who has served since June 2003, when he won a special election to succeed John Pippy, who was elected to the state Senate.

Advertise with us

Mr. Mustio was appreciative and humbled by the support in his district, which has a slight Democratic registration advantage.

"I attribute our success to very strong, proactive constituent work," he said. "I knocked on more than 6,000 doors in my district and I refused legislative perks -- I use my own car and cell phone."

He said campaigning door-to-door is the best part of the job.

"When people tell me in their own words about their difficulties with prescription drugs and property taxes, I can speak with authority and passion about those issues and visualize how these issues affect people," Mr. Mustio said. "I will continue to be proactive."

The district covers Findlay, Moon, North Fayette and parts of Collier and Robinson and 10 North Hills communities.

Advertise with us

46th District

Saying he had a message that connected with voters, Cecil lawyer Jesse White has became the first new state representative elected in the 46th District in a generation, as he defeated Republican Paul Snatchko.

The two were vying for the seat of 26-year incumbent Rep. Victor J. Lescovitz, D-Midway, who is retiring.

The race featured detailed proposals about property tax reform, term limits and a smaller Legislature from Mr. White, 28, who is also a small business owner, and Mr. Snatchko, 30, a McDonald councilman and political consultant.

Both candidates previously challenged Mr. Lescovitz.

Advertise with us

Mr. White said his top priority will be to create an economic resource center, which became the centerpiece of his campaign. It will allow local government and nonprofit agencies to connect with grant writers, who can assist in applying for grants and loans.

The Washington County-based 46th District extends into Oakdale and parts of South Fayette and McDonald in Allegheny County, and into Frankfort Springs and Hanover in Beaver County.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.