To be a lawyer or not to be a lawyer is often the question when it comes to electing a district judge. But not this year in the district around Beaver, because both Democratic nominee Bill Braslawsce and Republican nominee Tim Finn are lawyers.

"I've been around, with 26 years in practice," Mr. Finn, 52, of Vanport, said. "I've been in probably 50 different courtrooms. ... I've got the experience, and I want the job."

Mr. Braslawsce, meanwhile, also cited his education and his experience both in and out of the courtroom as qualifying factors, including a long list of volunteer service and 12 years in the military. He retired as a captain in the U.S. Army.

District judges handle small-claims civil court cases and are the first line in the criminal court system, issuing search and arrest warrants and presiding over preliminary hearings, which determine whether prosecutors have enough evidence to continue to trial.

Advertise with us

They are not required to be lawyers, but if they are not, they must pass a test on basic legal knowledge. There are nine magistrates in Beaver County, but none of the other seats are contested.

Mr. Finn faces an uphill battle; the district, which covers Beaver, Bridgewater, Vanport, Brighton, Midland, Industry, Ohioville and Glasgow, has a 2-1 Democratic registration edge.

"There's a large number of independents and others," he said, "but obviously I can't get elected without a lot of votes from my Democratic friends."

Describing himself as a "perennial candidate" -- he ran unsuccessfully for district attorney in 1995 and 1999 -- Mr. Finn sees himself as someone who "can get to the heart of a matter and do what's right."

He said in a race for an office that is not particularly political, "some could look at it as a popularity contest or a beauty contest. Hopefully I'm going to be elected instead on the basis of my character and judgment."

Advertise with us

Mr. Braslawsce, 41, of Beaver, meanwhile, said even though he's primarily a defense attorney -- which makes him no natural friend to the law enforcement community -- his character and judgment got him the endorsement of the county Fraternal Order of Police.

A tougher endorsement, perhaps, was that of his own father.

"He sat me down and asked me, 'Are you qualified to sit for the job? Can you serve the community?' All the tough questions."

An hour's grilling convinced Mr. Braslawsce that this really is what he wants to do. "This is the way I can be of service to my community," he said. "This is the way I can give something back."

He said he believes the goal is "being fair and equal. You don't pervert justice because someone is rich or poor."

Advertise with us

And he noted that in 13 years practicing law, "I've had 99 percent of the types of cases that would come before a magisterial district judge," handling an estimated 150 cases per year, going to trial about 20 times and appearing before magistrates "hundreds and hundreds" of times.

The winner will take the seat of Martin Schulte, who is retiring.