There will be a hand recount of eight ballot boxes in the contested primary election for Beaver County Common Pleas judge, but a petition to recount all 36,000 of the county's ballots has been withdrawn.

Attorneys for Deborah Kunselman and Kim Tesla worked out the deal yesterday morning, delaying a 10 a.m. hearing while they hammered out details. The hearing was further delayed while the parties observed a test of the optical scanners used to count ballots.

In a creative twist, the Tesla campaign can petition to have more ballot boxes hand-counted if results from the eight show a trend that points toward a potential victory.

Tesla, an assistant district attorney, lost the Democratic nomination by 190 votes to Kunselman, who is county solicitor. Kunselman won by about 2,000 votes among Republicans.

Advertise with us

The Tesla campaign petitioned the court, asking it to order a countywide recount, alleging problems in how the ballots were handled and counted. His campaign also petitioned to open eight individual ballot boxes -- out of 129 in the county -- and paid the fees normally associated with recounts.

Tesla's campaign agreed to withdraw the first petition, and Kunselman's agreed not to oppose the second.

In making the deal, though, the law teams determined the percentage of votes that would need to change for Tesla to win and applied it to the eight boxes, coming up with a figure of 21 -- if he picked up 21 or more votes in the eight boxes, that would show a trend that would overturn the election if it held countywide.

If Tesla picks up 21 or more votes, his campaign can petition to have more ballots recounted. If he picks up 20 or fewer, he agreed to give up the right to make further petitions.

"I'm thankful to counsel on both sides," Tesla said afterward. "I'm pleased with how the process was done."

Advertise with us

He said his campaign picked the eight precincts to be recounted based on when the ballot boxes were scanned. He said he had a 300-vote lead at 11 p.m. on the night of the primary, only to watch it vanish as the final precincts came in.

"We believe those were the ballot boxes that came in later in the evening," he said.

Kunselman did not comment, but her lawyer, Lazar Palnick, said she was pleased that the process would be "open and transparent" and concluded without protracted litigation.

"In the spirit of what we were trying to achieve, we said, 'OK, we're not afraid of any recount,' " he said.

Allan Opsitnick, a deputy solicitor who handles election issues for Allegheny County, has been appointed special master to oversee the hand recount, which will begin Wednesday.

Advertise with us

The count will be done by an official from Beaver County's elections bureau, with observers appointed by Kunselman and Tesla. The observers can dispute individual ballots, with Opsitnick ruling on the objections. If there are 21 or more disputed ballots that could swing to Tesla, the disputed ballots would go back in front of a judge for a ruling.

The case is being handled by senior Judge Martin J. O'Brien of Butler County. Beaver County's six judges recused themselves because the county's president judge is Robert Kunselman, Deborah Kunselman's father-in-law.