Cecil Smith said the "grace of God" helped him walk away from a plane crash that claimed the life of one of his friends and critically injured two others.
Bob Donaldson, Post-Gazette
FAA Aviation Safety Inspectors Warren Hall, left, and Joe McBride examine the wreckage of a Cessna 180 airplane modified to carry skydivers yesterday at the Beaver Valley Airport. One skydiver was killed and the pilot and two other skydivers were injured when the plane crashed on takeoff.
Click photo for larger image.
Wanting a better view of the fall foliage on the way to a sky-diving jump Wednesday, Smith climbed into the rear of the Cessna 180 and knelt behind the pilot's seat, the only seat in the plane.
Having the seat to brace against after the plane's right wing struck a tree on takeoff may have helped him avoid more serious injury, Smith, 48, of Rochester, said last night from his hospital bed at UPMC Presbyterian, where he was in fair condition.
But his friend Nancy Elm, 48, of Bellevue, died from injuries in the accident at the grassy airstrip used by the Beaver Valley Sky Divers club in New Sewickley, Beaver County.
The pilot, Emil Kindelberger Jr., 81, who owned and operated the plane and lived on the property used by the club, and Tim McGraw, 50, West Mayfield, were in critical condition last night at UPMC Presbyterian.
Smith's voice grew heavy with sadness as he spoke of the loss of his friend, whom he had known for 23 years.
As he spoke, his left leg was in a brace to protect his injured knee, which he said may require surgery. He also had stitches above his left eye and in his head, suffered a concussion and had extensive bruises.
Still, he said he planned to sky-dive again.
"I just love it. It's a way of life," said Smith, a salesman in Coraopolis who said he has had more than 4,300 jumps in the last 30 years.
Nancy Elm's sister, Claire Groll said her sister had the same love for the sport.
"She died doing what she loved," said Groll, of McCandless, adding that her sister had more than 3,600 jumps over the last 22 years.
"This was a risk we all knew," said Groll.
"We all were aware of it. She took it willingly.
"Had she been one of the survivors, she would have gone back up in the plane as soon as she was well enough."
She said her sister, who never married, was a doting aunt to her two young girls, visiting them every Monday.
A Bellevue resident, Elm grew up in Avalon and was a lease manager for the company that manages Gateway Center.
Three times a week during the summer, and on Saturdays and Sundays at other times of the year, she was sky-diving, Groll said.
"This will be with us forever," Karl Poruben, president of Beaver Valley Sky Divers, said of the accident. He described Elm as having a "very strong passion for the sport" and said she was a good instructor for other jumpers.
Smith said Elm had an infectious smile and was an "ambassador of the sport."
He said the plane was taking off to the east Wednesday, with Elm sitting on the floor next to the pilot and McGraw kneeling next to him, when the plane's right wing struck a tree bordering the runway.
I saw it right before it hit," Smith said. "I just said, 'Whoa! Whoa!' "
He said he just had time to brace himself before the plane plummeted nose first into the ground.
Despite his leg injury, he said he was able to get out and help rescuers remove the other two injured men from the plane.
Two investigators from the Federal Aviation Administration pored over the plane wreckage yesterday searching for clues about what went wrong. Such an investigation typically takes weeks if not months to complete.
The wreckage, smeared with blood and aircraft fluids, was dragged from the field where it crashed to a spot alongside the sky divers' clubhouse. Both wings on the red-and-white Cessna were broken, and the fuselage was snapped behind the cabin.
Both Poruben and McGraw's mother, Kitty McGraw, said the sky divers had faith in Kindelberger's piloting skill despite his age. Smith said Kindelberger was 81.
"He could fly by the seat of his pants, and healthwise, he's OK," McGraw said. "They would have never hesitated to go up in an airplane with Emil."
"I have absolute faith in his ability as an aircraft pilot," said Poruben. "The jumpers that were on board that aircraft had no problem with Emil."
FAA records show that Kindelberger received his pilot's certification in 1966. The agency's database on accidents, which goes back to 1974, shows that Kindelberger had one prior accident in July 1978.
Smith said that accident occurred when a diver's parachute opened prematurely and tangled around the plane. Kindelberger was able to keep the plane in the air until several divers and then, he, too, jumped from the plane, Smith said.
"I met him 32 years ago," Smith said of Kindelberger. "As far as I'm concerned, he's the best I've ever flown with."
It could not be determined when Kindelberger's last check-up or in-flight testing occurred, but he had to pass both a physical and a flight test every two years in order to remain a certified pilot.
National Transportation Safety Board records show that the plane involved in the crash that killed Elm was also involved in two accidents in 1968, one at Kindelberger's air strip. Government records available online do not show who the pilot was in either case.
Smith also was involved in another accident in 1997. He said last night that it was similar to the accident that occurred Wednesday but that no one was fatally injured.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.