The Peters Township School District is being sued for $7 million by general contractor Nello Construction, which says the district has not paid  for work already completed on the new Peters Township High School, which has been open to students since January.

The district entered into a construction contract with Nello back in June of 2018 and agreed to pay Nello the sum of $47,842,000 for its services.

Dean Falavolito, executive vice president and general counsel for Nello Construction, said the suit, filed Oct. 20 in Washington County Court of Common Pleas, has two elements: unpaid contract balance and costs for work disruptions due to site conditions, design issues and COVID-related issues.

“As to the unpaid contract work, the school district is improperly holding 4.855% retainage on the project, when it should have long ago been reduced to 2.5% or even 2% or lower,” Mr. Falavolito said. “They have been using the school since January and the only remaining item to complete is the natatorium, which is ongoing due to a delay which is detailed in the complaint,” he said.

Advertise with us

“The value of the ‘punch list work’ for which the school district is holding retention is not more than $100,000, if that, but they are holding almost $2 million and they refuse to give us a detailed breakdown as required by the Pennsylvania Procurement Code,” Mr. Falavolito added.

The lawsuit states soon after Nello began work on the project, it was “beset with extremely differing and poor site conditions including roads that were nothing more than several feet of mud.”

The suit goes on to state the conditions caused delays to Nello’s foundation, masonry, concrete and steel work and also forced Nello to perform road repairs and reconstruct temporary roadways that were the responsibility of other contractors.

Additionally, Nello contends there were multiple delays in its caisson, concrete and foundation work because of lack of proper building lines in the field and lack of building lines and dimensions on the drawings.

In late March 2020, Gov. Tom Wolf shut down all non-essential businesses including construction projects, but by the first week of April, it was determined that school construction projects could legally continue.

Advertise with us

The suit contends Nello and its subcontractors were “simply unable to get the necessary workers, many of whom were elderly and/or at risk,” and that lack of laborers and materials/supplies continued throughout the project.

“The school district’s position of working at ‘full speed’ though a pandemic constitutes active interference, was dangerous and forced Nello to operate at a highly inefficient and costly manner,” stated the lawsuit, which went on to say, “By being forced to work through a pandemic, Nello suffered extensive financial damages.”

Jessica Quinn-Horgan, counsel for the Peters Township School District, provided a written statement regarding the lawsuit, which read:

“The recent accusations levied by Nello Construction against Peters Township School District for nonpayment of work are inaccurate. The district has paid for all work items Nello and its subcontractors have completed that have been accepted by the project architect and construction manager related to the new high school.

“As permitted by law and contract, the district is properly withholding funds in retainage for work items that are either incomplete or do not meet the contract specifications. The district has and will continue to work diligently on behalf of community taxpayers to ensure that all work related to the new high school is done right and completed pursuant to the contract requirements.”

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.